Should Cotto Rematch Margarito right away if he beats Pacman?

[Unknown Champ]

I think he should try to reclaim his name once and for all if he beats manny by figthing margs, then he should fight shane or may. Your thoughts?

[flyest1]

I want to see that rematch so bad. I think so and I believe that's what Arum wants also at the Garden

[El Angel]

That's what I want to see happen. I think Cotto wants it too. To prove to himself he's better than Marg.

[El Chicano]

Bad move, he'll get stopped again. I hope he don't think he can do what Shane did.

[paulf]

I think Margarito will stop him again, but we'll see.

[Navyboxer1109]

Not that I think that Marg deserves to ever step in a ring again if he cheated, which is still speculation, but yes, I would love to see Cotto take him on again, and see the diffence between Margs confident demeanor in the cotto fight, and his look of total bewilderment in the Mosely fight. The eyes don't lie brothers, and if he has that same consternated look on his face that he did with shane when he steps in with Cotto, it will tell the tale of a fight where a fighter with minimal punching power could literally maul a heavy handed boxer with better skills and that had never been bruised so badly even when fighting with Real punchers, in his entire career. I say bring it on. Let the truth be brought to light.

[PAC-BOY]

he should fight him no matter what the out come is

[Story]

he should fight him no matter what the out come is

I agree.
Cotto wins this one IMO.

[We want Floyd]

Hell no, what would even be a bigger blow to Margarita is not Cotto whippin' his @ss in a rematch, but denying him of a big payday after spending a whole year under suspension w/ 0 earnings.

Can I see Cotto win in a rematch, hell yes, the only difference that Mosley did against Margarita was he wisely held Margarita at the right moment. Margarita is not the hard to figure out.

But, Cotto has this whole machismo thing, he doesn't f**kin' clinch. Clinching is fine, as long as you don't do it ala Ruiz/Hatton.

Shane showed the blueprint already, and it ain't all that complicated. I really would not do anything different with Cotto's gameplan if a rematch were to happen, I would just add the clinching.

[Pepe Smith]

I used to be a big fan of Margarito, I even defended him when people were accusing him of ducking Paul Williams. But Margarito should not be allowed to lace up boxing gloves ever again.