WTF with the P4P List? Marquez #5, Mosley #3?

[NAPO]

Lol what has boxing become?

[Iceta]

yeah but paul got schooled by quintana.

He avenged it though. I was going to make another post about another fighter til I saw your Rican nuthugging ass jump on this thread. As much as I think John deserves to be in the top ten P4P, I can't get that thought out of my head about him nearly getting KOd by Juarez in the final stages of both fights. I'm on the fence about him. But his longevity should be looked at.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

He avenged it though. I was going to make another post about another fighter til I saw your Rican nuthugging ass jump on this thread. As much as I think John deserves to be in the top ten P4P, I can't get that thought out of my head about him nearly getting KOd by Juarez in the final stages of both fights. I'm on the fence about him. But his longevity should be looked at.

John did beat JMM and Juarez, but what he have done besides that?

Look at my P4P rniings at tell what you think about it.

They are in the link I have in my sig that says My Rankings(Obviously)

[JM1]

this is bull****. floyd beating a small lightweight who moved up to welter looking fat, weak and slow means nothing. he cant even KO jmm

[Ekscape]

FU(K Ring Magazine. Ill never look at ring again. Its bull****.
This peckerhead comes in and beats a blow up LW @ WW, and hes really a SFW! AND he gets the #2 spot!!!!! WTF did JMM DO do bad to lose his #2 spot? He should get to keep it for the reason he fought a SWW/MW and went 12 ****in rounds!
Cotto has fought better opposition than Mayweather and gotten beat down and come back and Cotto fights..he dont run,and he 's #9 WTF were they thinking. The old Ring wouldnt have let this **** happen!!!!!!

LOL

[Ekscape]

this is bull****. floyd beating a small lightweight who moved up to welter looking fat, weak and slow means nothing. he cant even KO jmm

LOL

[Silencers]

Well JMM lost, he should get dropped even if he lost at welterweight against a welterweight. I don't really have a problem with Mosley being number 3. I kinda do have a problem with Mayweather being number 2 though, I didn't rank him before the fight and I don't think 1 win should put him at number 2.

[JM1]

LOL

why should i be mad? im upset with the bull**** rankings

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Well JMM lost, he should get dropped even if he lost at welterweight against a welterweight. I don't really have a problem with Mosley being number 3. I kinda do have a problem with Mayweather being number 2 though, I didn't rank him before the fight and I don't think 1 win should put him at number 2.

Since Cotto-Mosley happend!!!!

Cotto
W12 Mosley
KO6 Gomez
TKO11L Margarito
TKO5 jennings
SD12 Clottey

Mosley
L12 Cotto
Won KO12 Mayorga(He was losing in one ofthe cards and was a draw on the other one going to the 12. The last part Im not 100% sure)
Won KO Margarito


How is shane body of work is deserving to be even ranked above Cotto?

And thats saying P4P wise, because in teh WW rankings Cotto should be the #1 ranked WW.

Looked at how manny win loses and how many fights have Cotto over Mosley at WW !!!!!

[Iceta]

Since Cotto-Mosley happend!!!!

Cotto
W12 Mosley
KO6 Gomez
TKO11L Margarito
TKO5 jennings
SD12 Clottey

Mosley
L12 Cotto
Won KO12 Mayorga(He was losing in one ofthe cards and was a draw on the other one going to the 12. The last part Im not 100% sure)
Won KO Margarito


How is shane body of work is deserving to be even ranked above Cotto?

Collazo and Mayorga are better than Jennings and Gomez put together though. That's something to take into consideration. And HBO fucked up the Mosley-Clottey fight. Shane had no control over that. But to me, there resumes are about even. I'd have to see Collazo and Judah duke it out if you wanted me to really make a fair conclusion of who has the edge. Mosley's victory over Collazo happened before the Cotto fight. Are we talking P4P or 147? I don't remember. Lol.