Comparing Floyd & Pac Against Common Opponents

[blacksocks]

1) Marquez:

Pac fought the best Marquez in his best division.

Floyd fought an overweight, slower, lighter puncher Marquez in Floyd's division.

2) Hatton:

Aaginst Hatton, Pac was 10-7 in the first round and almost killed him in the second with a KO. That was in a division Hatton was King and undefeated.

Floyd made Hatton come up to his division and was getting beat in the earlier rounds before he figured him out in the late rounds.

3) De La Hoya:

Floyed got a disputed SD against ODLH, in a division just a step above his weightclass.

Against Pac, ODLH didn't win any rounds, got a 10-8 score in the 7th and probably on the 8th and didn't answer the bell on the 9th. Pac went up 2 weightclasses.

[ThePunchingBag]

1) Marquez:

Pac fought the best Marquez in his best division.

Floyd fought an overweight, slower, lighter puncher Marquez in Floyd's division.

2) Hatton:

Aaginst Hatton, Pac was 10-7 in the first round and almost killed him in the second with a KO. That was in a division Hatton was King and undefeated.

Floyd made Hatton come up to his division and was getting beat in the earlier rounds before he figured him out in the late rounds.

3) De La Hoya:

Floyed got a disputed SD against ODLH, in a division just a step above his weightclass.

Against Pac, ODLH didn't win any rounds, got a 10-8 score in the 7th and probably on the 8th and didn't answer the bell on the 9th. Pac went up 2 weightclasses.

This describes in detail why Pac is P4P #1 and Floyd is not. Floyd nut huggers will try to fabricate excuses, but the evidence right there is plain as day.

[Kevin Jesus]

Mayweather went 24 close rounds with Castillo.
Hatton KO's Castillo in 4 rounds.
Mayweather KO's Hatton in 10 rounds.


Miguel Cotto decisions Mosley.
Margarito TKO's Cotto.
Mosley TKO's Margarito.


Taylor went 24 close rounds with Hopkins.
Pavlik TKO's/Decisions Taylor.
Hopkins Humiliates Pavlik.


This describe in details why triangle theories don't work.

[-EX-]

This is irrelevant to them stepping in the ring against each other...

[ThePunchingBag]

This is irrelevant to them stepping in the ring against each other...

It is however relevant to P4P status..

[Sudo]

1) argument can be made that pacman lost both fights.

2) when floyd beat hatton he was undefeated, when pacman fought him, hatton already looked bad against luzcano, and let's say solid against malignaggi

3) floyd fought against ODLH in his division, pacman fought against drained ODLH.

And i really don't like Floyd, he just talks a lot and avoids real competition in his weight class.

[JOM'S]

may not be irrelevant when facing each other ....

but good enough for any p4pdiscussion puposes ...

[-GR -]

Hatton wanted 147 and fought there already. Hatton also weighs in the 150s at JWW. DLH fight should have been a UD and JMM wasn't slow, he was just slower than floyd. Funny how you don't mentioned how weight drained dlh was and how even freddie talked about it

[JOM'S]

1) argument can be made that pacman lost both fights.

2) when floyd beat hatton he was undefeated, when pacman fought him, hatton already looked bad against luzcano, and let's say solid against malignaggi

3) floyd fought against ODLH in his division, pacman fought against drained ODLH.

And i really don't like Floyd, he just talks a lot and avoids real competition in his weight class.

these is what we are saying ... all those fights means something for one purpose or the other ...