Where is Bivol on the Pound 4 Pound list now?

[CaneloBlue]

I say he’s definitely somewhere in the top 5.

[W1LL]

Why? He defended his title against a much smaller man. He needs a few more titles and/or Elite names on his resume. Fight and beat Artur Beterbiev, then he may be "Top 5 P4P."

[Superbee]

He beat THE guy in a landslide ... he should be way up there ...

[The Big Dunn]

I would put him ahead of Canelo but behind Crawford, Usyk, Inoue, Spence and Fury.

[gamesworn]

For Bivol, 6-10 . I think Canelo still deserves to be in the top 5, he fought a bigger, better and live fighter today, it doesn't remove his previous wins. I think Usyk deserves the number 1 spot now.

[CaneloBlue]

Why? He defended his title against a much smaller man. He needs a few more titles and/or Elite names on his resume. Fight and beat Artur Beterbiev, then he may be "Top 5 P4P."

He just beat THE p4p number one who just unified a division 7 pounds below his. He’s definitely in the list.

[HeadShots]

he's top 5 definitely.


He's also small for LHW. Don't think he's fought a smaller LHW yet.

these are grown man weight divisions, they don't get bigger as they age.

[BZBEE]

I would put him ahead of Canelo but behind Crawford, Usyk, Inoue, Spence and Fury.

i agree

[YGriffith]

Why? He defended his title against a much smaller man. He needs a few more titles and/or Elite names on his resume. Fight and beat Artur Beterbiev, then he may be "Top 5 P4P."

Canelo is not the "much smaller man" they weighed around the same and Kovalev was bigger and a harder puncher than Bivol.

[hhh1200]

Old

Canelo
Crawford
Inoue
Errol Spence Jr.
Josh Taylor
Beterbiev
Lomachenko
Jermell
Roman Gonzalez
Nonito Donaire


New

Crawford
Inoue
Canelo
Bivol
Beterbiev
Spence Jr
Loma
Jermell
Gonzalez
Donaire - Taylor

Sometimes you beat a guy but you don't necessarily jump over him. P4P is mythical and fights of similar weights. Beterbiev stops all those dudes if they were 175s. I think he stops Bivol in 2020 but Bivol may have waited him out along enough and he does get a ranking above him for beating a P4P

Just keep Fury and Usyk off the list.