Comments Thread For: Would A Win Over Savannah Marshall Silence Claressa Shields' Critics?

[BIGPOPPAPUMP]

By Corey Erdman - Claressa Shields fights tend to follow a familiar pattern. There is about a thirty second period at the beginning of the fight in which her opponents look like they may be able to bother her in some capacity, until it becomes clear what Shields is doing.
[Click Here To Read More]

[buddyr]

no. because then they will create another fighter she's "ducking" and will win. It will never stop. After this fight, those claiming Marshall will win will disappear. For the record, I like Marshall. She's a good fighter

[dannnnn]

Doubt it.

[djbiancafrost]

I loved that face to face video yesterday where Marshall really made Shield mad. I dont know who will win for now but i just want to see them fight. That division isnt so deep so you wont really know the number 1 or 2 is really that good. I still believe the best women fight right now is Taylor and Serrano, Shields-Marshall is a good addition to the now fiery womens boxing.

[Wacked_Out]

No because people think her personality is abhorrent.

[BodyBagz]

Women boxing will still suck

[DaNeutral.]

Depends on what they are criticising her for. If the criticism is that she's an utter ball bag then the chances are that if she beats Marshall she will become an even bigger ball bag. Most critics have not got a problem with her Boxing ability.

[ifc]

Marshall would be the only good win in her weight class. Shields keeps calling out lightweights Taylor and Serrano or McCaskill who is a lightweight fighting at 147. Claressa will have to go back to mma because she won't get credit for beating up lightweights.

[Zaroku]

I’d f both of them

***.

[fourtheboys96]

I have no problem with her boxing talent but as with most women's boxing fights, I find her fights lacking in violence. She cant even stun or opponents.
IDK if my memory serves me right but Christy Martin and of course Rijker and even Laila Ali has more entertainment value than her.

Her personality is a different story. Nothing to like about. Supporting and even praising out of the ring violence.