What would you say is Mayweather's best win?

[dondi330]

Corrales(Suprise domination), Hoya( Hoya tried to take advantage by making the weight in his favor, stiil lost), Castillo(showed guts), Judah(poised and took some good hard shots from a fast and hard hitting Zab) then Gatti( because he did exactly what he was supposed to do DOMINATE a B class fighter, no let down. In that order.

[Wiley Hyena]

Clearly, Floyd's greatest win was over the aged Oscar DeLaHoya. His win over Hatton is a distant second only because it was a knockout. Everything else is as tasteless and interesting as 3 day old soda.

[Shadows]

His absolute domination of Chico is his best fight by far. Floyd at 130 was amazing.

[Junito-Rulez]

1) Jose Luis Castillo
2) Diego Corrales

Floyd's two(three) big legendaries wins that cemented his legacy. You could make excuses for all his other big wins but not those two. Castillo and Corrales are untouchables.

[Wiley Hyena]

1) Jose Luis Castillo
2) Diego Corrales

Floyd's two(three) big legendaries wins that cemented his legacy. You could make excuses for all his other big wins but not those two. Castillo and Corrales are untouchables.

Of course the problem with Castillo is that Castillo really won the first fight.....
But, at 130 I like Mayweather over most others. He was admittedly great there. The problems started when he moved up.

[Doctor_Tenma]

In order

Corrales
JLC
DLH
Jesus Chavez
Ganero Hernandez
Zab Judah
Hatton

[Bushidō]

I know beating De La Hoya really put him on the map, but do you think he's had a better win? I'd probably say De La Hoya due to the weight disadvantage and the significance, but beating Corrales and Castillo was pretty damn good also. I imagine most will say De La Hoya and probably call me a fool for even questiong it, but I want to see from true Floyd fans if you think he's had a better conquest.

Corrales i think there is a poll of this. the win over Hatton was nice too

[SOPH~ REP.]

corrales(suprise domination), hoya( hoya tried to take advantage by making the weight in his favor, stiil lost), castillo(showed guts), judah(poised and took some good hard shots from a fast and hard hitting zab) then gatti( because he did exactly what he was supposed to do dominate a b class fighter, no let down. In that order.

hands down the castillo fights cuz it prepared him 4 de al hoya

[Al Haymon]

Clearly, Floyd's greatest win was over the aged Oscar DeLaHoya. His win over Hatton is a distant second only because it was a knockout. Everything else is as tasteless and interesting as 3 day old soda.

I'm sorry, but I disagree. I found the Corrales fight interesting and impressive.

[STILL_DETOX]

corrales was the fight that put him on the map in the boxing world
castillo fights proved he could deal with adversity
gatti put him on the map in the ppv world
oscar fight made him a superstar

all in all i think corrales or castillo was his best wins

well said