Legitmately Floyd is REAL WW but Cotto/Shane/Marg/Clottey

[Tyson2k7]

Are not WW. These guys are MW fighters in reality.

Floyd doesn't rehydrate like these guys do. Pacman is also a legit WW since he doesn't rehydrate like those guys above. JMM is JW since also doesn't balloon up.

[mindreader]

How are they MW when MW rehydrate to SMW or higher?

95% of all fighter rehydrate floyd and manny use to also when they were in lower weight classes. So why is there problem now?

[Doctor_Tenma]

A better way to say this is, Mayweather is a Jr WW. WWs don't come into the ring weighing 146-148, Jr WWs do.

[Bhopreign]

How are they MW when MW rehydrate to SMW or higher?

95% of all fighter rehydrate floyd and manny use to also when they were in lower weight classes. So why is there problem now?

What? Floyd would gain no more than 4-5 pounds at the lower weights or am I missing something?

[Pullcounter]

Are not WW. These guys are MW fighters in reality.

Floyd doesn't rehydrate like these guys do. Pacman is also a legit WW since he doesn't rehydrate like those guys above. JMM is JW since also doesn't balloon up.

can't reallly call anyone legit until they are proven in that weight division.

[Pullcounter]

A better way to say this is, Mayweather is a Jr WW. WWs don't come into the ring weighing 146-148, Jr WWs do.

if floyd is a jr WW then why not fight jmm at jr WW?

[MANGLER]

How many more of these whinyass threads do we need? Mr boat buyer is a ****in WW now. He's grown into that weight. **** Marg. He's irrelevant now. But last yr, a fight shoulda happened, but Mr boat buyer had walked. He needs to fight SSM and Cotto now. But if Pac beats Cotto, he's legit at WW and that fight can't be criticized if it's at WW if Mr boat buyer does fight Pac.

[Doctor_Tenma]

if floyd is a jr WW then why not fight jmm at jr WW?

Marquez isn't even established at 140 neither? So what would be the difference? During the fight, Mayweather is still gonna come into the ring weighing 148 and Marquez 142-143.

[Spray_resistant]

Are not WW. These guys are MW fighters in reality.

Floyd doesn't rehydrate like these guys do. Pacman is also a legit WW since he doesn't rehydrate like those guys above. JMM is JW since also doesn't balloon up.

In theory your right, but as stated here earlier just about everyone balloons up after the weigh in so it is all on even terms. Keep in mind Floyd doesn't have to compete at WW and neither does Manny, the standards shouldn't be changed just for them.

[jazluvr]

Mangler; Mr boat buyer is a ****in WW now. He's grown into that weight. **** Marg. He's irrelevant now. But last yr, a fight shoulda happened, but Mr boat buyer had walked. He needs to fight SSM and Cotto now. But if Pac beats Cotto, he's legit at WW and that fight can't be criticized.

I agree with this. Great point.