Comments Thread For: Canelo Builds, Taylor Rises: BoxingScene Competition Index July 2021 Update

[aboutfkntime]

...






that is obviously not a P4P list

it ranks by resume, but only includes recent fights... which is ridiculous criteria for P4P

P4P is... style/skills/form... in that order... with slight consideration given to resume

judging by resume is a recipe for proving yourself wrong... e.g. ... having a better resume did not help Lomachenko with Teofimo Lopez

P4P fighters lose to non-P4P ranked fighters all the time






...

[aboutfkntime]

Might agree on that from but It’s not a P4P list. It compares across weight classes but it’s comparing specific things.

aaah ok... I knew there would be more to it

you deserve a $20 bonus from everyone who posts... " poor P4P list "






...

[aboutfkntime]

...






the " unique fights " category is interesting... would like some more info on that

like... what qualifies as unique... and how do they separate/rank unique opponents






...

[crold1]

...






the " unique fights " category is interesting... would like some more info on that

like... what qualifies as unique... and how do they separate/rank unique opponents






...

that’s easy. That category is so if one guy beats thr same guy 2-3 times (think Navarrete-Dogboe), it is one unique opponent. Both wins still count toward the pt total

[aboutfkntime]

that’s easy. That category is so if one guy beats thr same guy 2-3 times (think Navarrete-Dogboe), it is one unique opponent. Both wins still count toward the pt total

aah right, I was reading too much into it

thnx






...

[BeLikeWater]

It’s based on past fights, not future fights. Spence has overall fought much better competition than Teofimo.

He beat Loma who was 1 or 2 p4p best and he has all the belts. Beating porter and garcia doesn’t make you a top level fighter since neither of them are even close to be being on the p4p list.. What a disgrace of a list.

[MikeyG]

Thanks Cliff for trying another perspective on ranking. Interesting stuff.