Summing up the scoring of the Charlo-Castano fight.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

1. Draw was fair.

2. Close win for Castano is fair.

3. No way in hell Charlo won that fight.

4. The 117-111 card was disgraceful.

5. The 10-8 round for Charlo on the 114-113 card was also dubious.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Gonna rewatch it as soon as quality version becomes available on YouTube, Dailymotion etc.

[_Rexy_]

I thought the 10-8 was laughable, but after that round I jokingly said "They're gonna make that a 10-8 round like the Korobov fight"

[Madison Boxing]

charlo lost the damn fight, a draw wasnt fair, he LOST

[Outwest Exp 355]

I thought the 10-8 was laughable, but after that round I jokingly said "They're gonna make that a 10-8 round like the Korobov fight"

Fortunately the 10-8 round came on the scorecard that had Castano winning the fight 114-113.

[HOF Hater]

Fortunately the 10-8 round came on the scorecard that had Castano winning the fight 114-113.

It's crazy the amount of slack PBC fighters are given. And how rabid the PBC fanbase are. They're not coincidentally almost all black but that's besides the point. Most of the PBC fighters can fight but they aren't ELITE. This fight wasn't an isolated event:

Wilder winning wide against Fury in their 1st fight (joke)
Wilder being UP on scorecards against Ortiz in their 1st fight (joke)
Jermell being UP on scorecards in Harrison rematch (joke)
Jermall getting 10-8 round against Korobov (joke)
Jermell getting 10-8 round against Castano (joke)
Spence being allowed to throw 100+ low-blows against Porter (joke)
'
If I'm Canelo I do NOT fight either Charlo unless it's on DAZN. They will rob him just like they rob everyone. It's a disgrace platform

[Outwest Exp 355]

It's crazy the amount of slack PBC fighters are given. And how rabid the PBC fanbase are. They're not coincidentally almost all black but that's besides the point. Most of the PBC fighters can fight but they aren't ELITE. This fight wasn't an isolated event:

Wilder winning wide against Fury in their 1st fight (joke)
Wilder being UP on scorecards against Ortiz in their 1st fight (joke)
Jermell being UP on scorecards in Harrison rematch (joke)
Jermall getting 10-8 round against Korobov (joke)
Jermell getting 10-8 round against Castano (joke)
Spence being allowed to throw 100+ low-blows against Porter (joke)
'
If I'm Canelo I do NOT fight either Charlo unless it's on DAZN. They will rob him just like they rob everyone. It's a disgrace platform

The platforms not going to matter. And please Canelo’s gotten more of his fair share of faulty decisions to try and throw shade at anyone. I’ve been saying this for years they need to remove ring side judges. They should be scoring the fight on a television monitor.

[whollisboxing]

1. Draw was fair.

2. Close win for Castano is fair.

3. No way in hell Charlo won that fight.

4. The 117-111 card was disgraceful.

5. The 10-8 round for Charlo on the 114-113 card was also dubious.

Charlo’s late rally made a draw more feasible so I won’t complain too much. I still thought Castano won at least 7 rounds and there is no way Charlo won 9.

I need to read the official rules on 10-8 rounds because I always assumed you needed to score a KD for that. As someone mentioned earlier, that takes away the incentive of weathering the storm and staying on your feet like Brian did.

[eco1]

1. Draw was fair.

2. Close win for Castano is fair.

3. No way in hell Charlo won that fight.

4. The 117-111 card was disgraceful.

5. The 10-8 round for Charlo on the 114-113 card was also dubious.

10-8 round????? I think only when a KO is applied it should be 10-8. Everything else is BS.

[STREET CLEANER]

I am fine with the draw or a Castano win. There were rounds that Castano only fought the last 30 seconds and those rounds could had gone either way since most of the round Charlo jabbed him in the middle of the ring.