POLL: Who did better against Cotto: Mosley vs Clottey

[THE REED]

I thought Clottey clearly and closely lost, I thought Cotto/Mosley was incredibly close but Cotto edged it.

Id have Mosley simply willing to throw more punches and Clottey trying to defend them... losing by not throwing enough, as usual.

[Del Coqui]

no brainer, Clottey did better vs Cotto. I got Clottey vs Mosley on speed, counterpunching and D

[ericsantos]

I thought the Cotto - Clottey fight was very close and could of went to either guy.

The Cotto - Mosley fight was a close but clear victory for Cotto. The best Mosley could of got was a draw imo.

So i give my vote to Clottey.

I think Mosley wins a close fight against Clottey based on being more active.

I agree with your post

[keepthemhandsup]

think clottely made it closer when he fought cotto than mosely did. TBF...cotto did have a cut in the clottely fight so we don't know how close it would had really been if cotto didn't get cut

[Pugilistic™]

My thoughts exactly.

But that doesn't mean I'm favoring Clottey over Mosley.

I'm picking Mosley to beat Clottey also.

[fallenloki]

I thought Clottey won the Cotto fight. Mosley one was a draw at best.

[Pullcounter]

lets throw margarito in this.

who did better against cotto and margo combined? mosley or clottey?

[Puya]

Who did better vs Cotto? Mosley or Clottey?

Clottey might not be the pushover everyone makes him out to be.

Cotto is a great fighter in his prime. Mosley is a great fighter who is 38.

I'm pretty split on this fight personally, but I give the edge to Mosley by UD.

For me Shane did better. Cotto had to fight Clottey with a big cut and he could see with 1 eye while taking hard shots from the temp blind side. And still Cotto did a decent job.

[Iceta]

I know I am probably in the minority, but I actually think Mosley did better against Cotto than Clottey did. Sure, Clottey landed more punches against Cotto than Mosley did. But they weren't as effective. They were peppering punches that had kind of an accumlative effect. Mosley hurt Cotto really bad several times in their fight. Combine this with the fact that Clottey got knocked down and lost the sixth round by a large margin. I could see that round being 10-8.

[freedom213]

Who did better vs Cotto? Mosley or Clottey?

Clottey might not be the pushover everyone makes him out to be.

Cotto is a great fighter in his prime. Mosley is a great fighter who is 38.

I'm pretty split on this fight personally, but I give the edge to Mosley by UD.

Clottey mainly cause of the cut though,