Who would give Mayweather a better chanllenge out of these opponents? For a comeback

[Doctor_Tenma]

Andre Berto
Carlos Quintana
Joshua Clottey
Luis Collazo
Juan Manuel Marquez


Ofcourse I'm talking about his comeback here.

[Tmann400]

clottey would give him a run for his money..he beats the rest handily

[da chosen 1]

the question is who would make him the most money for his come back

[Dan...]

Clottey is the toughest of those fights for mine.

[MANGLER]

Clottey would.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Clottey is the toughest of those fights for mine.

I knew people would say that, I kind of disagree because Clottey doesn't have a good workrate and isn't quick on his feet.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I'll say Carlos Quintana, Quintana is fast on his feet, has a good workrate, good hand speed and power.

[Tmann400]

I'll say Carlos Quintana, Quintana is fast on his feet, has a good workrate, good hand speed and power.

quintana just isnt on the same overrall level as clottey is...and on top of that i think quintana is done anyway

[Savino]

without a doubt the man he is set to face on sept the 19th would be the hardest test out of that list. Clottley would of been a decent contest too.

[Doctor_Tenma]

quintana just isnt on the same overrall level as clottey is...and on top of that i think quintana is done anyway

I'd pick Quintana to beat Clottey. I picked Clottey to beat Cotto, due to his style, Quintana could actually outbox Clottey. I'm surprised some would think Clottey is on another level, I don't see that.