Which is the better win, Crawford vs Postol or Canelo vs BJS?

[Citizen Koba]

Probably lean Pistol given his greater consistency but Saunders is the greater natural talent. Blows too hot and cold although I was very impressed with Saunders' composure on the big stage up to the point his face broke.

FWIW I consider Pistol to be Buds best win and Saunders to be Canelos 4th or Possibly 5th best official win.

[blowblow]

Billy Joe is elite?

i didn't say that.. i'm just asking who was his elite win?

[TernceBudCharlo]

i didn't say that.. i'm just asking who was his elite win?

Billy Joe is Canelo's best win to me. I don't consider controversial wins better.

[blowblow]

Billy Joe is Canelo's best win to me. I don't consider controversial wins better.

ok let's say BJS is his best win.. you right.. but may i know what was bud's elite win? he was p4p.

[TernceBudCharlo]

ok let's say BJS is his best win.. you right.. but may i know what was bud's elite win? he was p4p.

Nobody in boxing has an elite non controversial elite win except maybe Teofimo. Roman Gonzalez should be he got robbed.

[blowblow]

Nobody in boxing has an elite non controversial elite win except maybe Teofimo. Roman Gonzalez should be he got robbed.

im just talking about bud.. anyway you don't have to answer.. seems like there's non..

[TernceBudCharlo]

im just talking about bud.. anyway you don't have to answer.. seems like there's non..

That doesn't mean he can't be on the p4p list, nobody on the p4p list has an elite win with no controversy except Teofimo. Bud has more great dominating wins over really good fighters than any those guys.

[ShaneMosleySr]

Gamboa was undefeated and previously ranked in the pound for pound top ten before the Crawford fight.

im just talking about bud.. anyway you don't have to answer.. seems like there's non..

[#1PaperChamp]

Postol.

The odds in that fight were closer.

Postol had just knocked out Lucas Matthyssee.

He was the bigger man. It was only the second time Crawford had weighed above 139 in his career.

Crawford won every second of the fight.

Canelo-BJS was close before the KO.

Today I learned being up 6-2 in rounds is "close". Good ole NSB forums XD XD XD

[#1PaperChamp]

Billy Joe is Canelo's best win to me. I don't consider controversial wins better.

Danny Jacobs was a great win. Cotto was a great win. GGG was a great win. Trout and Lara were good wins. Callum Smith, BJS, and Kovalev were good wins. Mosley was a good win. Khan and JCC Jr were advertising fights...

Canelo has beaten several HOF fighters. Crawford literally might not have one single HOF fighter on his resume. Amazing.