Who has the best resume in this Era of Boxing?

[Jiddu Dali]

he is on the list.

I think Floyd has fought good fighters ( def not the best on that list), but I believe he will need to beat guys like Marquez, Pac, Mosley and or Cotto to cement his legacy NOW

[MANGLER]

I agree.....and IMO Oscar has a Top 5-10 P4P resume.....too bad he came up short in all the big fights

TBH, when I read the part of the OP where you specified it was just about who they fought, not who they beat, I thought this thread was designed for DLH to win homey.

[street bully]

How the hell do you guys decide on resume. I see resume on who you fought and beat or who you fought and deserved to beat. Oscar fought everybody, but he lost to everybody. I don't see his resume as spectacular in that sense. I mean he lost to Mosley, Trinidad, Mayweather, Pacquiao, Hopkins, and should have lost to Quartey and Sturm with the Whitker fight being a toss up. If anything I think Oscar is overrated, and is no ATG.

There were plenty of journeymen from the late 60s and 70s that fought each of Ali, Frazier, Foreman, Norton, and Holmens as well as the other top HWs and lost to all of them. Would you consider their resume spectacular since they had a number of L's? I wouldn't.

[Elie]

Oscar, easily. Next question.

[Toney Loc]

DLH's resume > Glencoff's.....by miles

No doubt. Just saying that Glen fought everyone.

Jones
Tarver
Woods
Gonzales
Dawson
Hopkins
Ottke

[Jiddu Dali]

I'd have Evander up there before JMM...

my bad


pulled a homer

I keep forgetting there is a HW division these days

[talip bin osman]

when u mean resume, does it mean all against a certain fighter's foes or just his wins?

if its the former, well ricardo mayorga should be among the best of em...

oscar, vernon 2X, shane, fernando, tito, spinks...

can u accept that view of mayorga?

it really depends how someone defines "resume"...

[JM1]

dela hoya. though he lost the big fights hes still got big names on his resume

[Jiddu Dali]

No doubt. Just saying that Glen fought everyone.

Jones
Tarver
Woods
Gonzales
Dawson
Hopkins
Ottke

I agree, but RJJ fought all of the same guys plus more

[-EX-]

I consider resume who you beat not just who you fought...if it was whoever you fought guys like Zab Judah could have pretty good resumes...

But the TS said just based on who you fought so its Oscar...