mayweather vs castillo 1 did castillo really get robbed???

[mrbigshot]

just rewatched the fight and it seems like castillo was robbed judged especially on punchstats

castillo outpunched and outconnected mayweather

i know floyd had a shoulder injury but did castillo really get robbed????

[Thread Stealer]

No, he took too long to get going and lost too many early rounds IMO.

Robbery is such an overused word. I put this in the category of fights like DLH-Whitaker, Pacquiao-Marquez, Leonard-Hagler, etc....

Fights like Holyfield-Lewis 1, Escalera-Everett, and the worst of all, Coggi-Gonzalez 1. Those were straight up robberies.

[MonsieurGeorges]

It was close one but IMO Floyd won and his win in the 2nd fight is undebatable.

[black.ink]

I think the slow start Castillo applied at the beginning had a big affect on the result as he clearly finished the fight as the confident fighter applying the right pressure to cut Mayweather off.

I think i had Mayweather up by 1 round after 12 rounds. Close fight, but not a robbery.