Should the loser of Diaz/Malinaggi retire?

[My Name Is...]

Diaz is young and finished school he clearly cant compete on the elite level. Same goes for Malinaggi. Should the loser retire?

Juan cant compete on an elite level? He gave Marquez all that he could handle... Was beating Nate before the cut.... And would beat Nate RIGHT NOW....

The ONLY fighters that will beat him for sure is Marquez and Pac.. Just two of the bess fighters in this generation, and #1 and 2 on P4P lists... You're an idiot...

GTFOH with this bull****.....

He could MAYBE beat Bradley.... Beat Nate... beat Hatton... Beats Amir Khan... Paulie....

Whats not ELITE about those fighters....

[My Name Is...]

What top fighter has either of them beat?

Katsidis, Freitas, Diaz, Jose Cotto.... Billy Irwin at the time was a good top teir fighter... So was Suico.. Beat a WORLD CHAMP, not some bum belt holder, at 21...

Shut up, just shut up....

[Silencers]

No, I think the loser might be able to claw his way back to another title shot, especially Diaz because of his connections with GBP and HBO's willingness to put him on the air, Malignaggi would find himself in a tough position though and would have a much harder road back.

[JM1]

taking a beating at one point of a boxers career is inevitable. the loser of this fight may continue fighting