Would calzaghe have gotten the decision (vs hopkins)if the judges had instant replay?

[STILL_DETOX]

[IMG]http://i112.***********.com/albums/n187/Detox_bucket/hopcalz-1.gif[/IMG]



if only they saw how calzaghe landed like 2 clean blows in 36min

[Joe2608]

If only they had seen Hopkins land all those illegal butts :O

[TheGreatAli]

It's time Hopkins fans let that fight go, Calzaghe was the clear victor in a close but competitive fight. It baffles me how every Hopkins fan conviniently scores it 114-113 for Hopkins and cries robbery at the same time. Firstly, 114-113 is the most you could have scored it for Hopkins and that would be a draw without the flash KD. Secondly, a 1 point win means it's a close fight and not a robbery, the most Calzaghe could have won by is 116-111 which is a 9-3 win on the scorecards.

[FLY TY]

[IMG]http://i112.***********.com/albums/n187/Detox_bucket/hopcalz-1.gif[/IMG]



if only they saw how calzaghe landed like 2 clean blows in 36min

hopkins would've gotten the decision if the judges had eyes and brains....

[Joe2608]

It's time Hopkins fans let that fight go, Calzaghe was the clear victor in a close but competitive fight. It baffles me how every Hopkins fan conviniently scores it 114-113 for Hopkins and cries robbery at the same time. Firstly, 114-113 is the most you could have scored it for Hopkins and that would be a draw without the flash KD. Secondly, a 1 point win means it's a close fight and not a robbery, the most Calzaghe could have won by is 116-111 which is a 9-3 win on the scorecards.

A good, intelligent post. Green K.

[Kevin Jesus]

Hopkins lost to a white boy.

But you know what i like about Hopkins? he said "I would never let a white boy beat me!"

Calzaghe might have won, but he did not 'beat' Hopkins. Calzaghe looked like the beaten one. Therefore, Hopkins didn't let a white boy beat him.

[djtmal]

why would anyone want to see hopkins lose in slow motion...?...its bad enough we had to watch him lose in regular speed...lol...maybe we'll see that the low blow that had him reeling didn't actually land....lol

[TheGreatAli]

Hopkins lost to a white boy.

But you know what i like about Hopkins? he said "I would never let a white boy beat me!"

Calzaghe might have won, but he did not 'beat' Hopkins. Calzaghe looked like the beaten one. Therefore, Hopkins didn't let a white boy beat him.

He didn't let him but he did turn out to be the loser.

[djtmal]

Hopkins lost to a white boy.

But you know what i like about Hopkins? he said "I would never let a white boy beat me!"

Calzaghe might have won, but he did not 'beat' Hopkins. Calzaghe looked like the beaten one. Therefore, Hopkins didn't let a white boy beat him.

i guess these hopkins nuthuggers gotta have something to hold on to...still, another legit loss to someone close to his size with equal talent...

[Tmann400]

as a Hopkins fan..that fight was two evenly matched fighters with a very bad style clash that resulted in a very ugly fight that was hard to see who actually WON