Who put up the better challenge?

[lparm]

you punked me? How is my list biased? I asked about his comeback/tuneup opponents. A comeback/tuneup fight really isn't supposed to be against an elite fighter. Learn to read and interpret.

So I guess a prime RJJ didn't fight Calzaghe while coming back from the Tarver loss. Including only wins when he lost just last year to an old Calzaghe is a biased list.

[Don Johnson]

So I guess a prime RJJ didn't fight Calzaghe while coming back from the Tarver loss. Including only wins when he lost just last year to an old Calzaghe is a biased list.

The tarver fight and calzaghe fight were 3 years apart. After his losses to tarver and Johnson, He came back in july of 2006 to fight Prince Badi ajamu, fought in 2007 against Anthony Hanshaw, then in January of 2008 he fought Felix Trinidad. He fights Joe C in november of 08, loses and makes a comeback against sheika and lacy. None of these fighters had a chance to win(thats why they're called tuneups),they just provided a litmus as to how much Roy had left. ****** biased asses like you are why this forum is in the shape it is today.

[Steak]

Chip Douglas? Isnt that a character from the Fairly Oddparents?

[Jone2ts]

Hanshaw was to me...Why Joe's fans hatin over a win that has nothing to do with Joe? Is it cause his resume looking a little sparse? Look Joe won the fight and if dude is serious keeps claiming Roy was prime for Joe it's really funny. joe won the fight move on, so what he couldn't KO him. Im not sure i've ever seen Joe KO anybody, he usually gets knocked down.