Is Manny Pacquiao the greatest active boxer?

[burnerdafck]

i think pacqiao is better than floyd regarding on achivement..floyd eat dust while his belt cant even make a dust of its own..but to put him on top 5 is questionable..

[JM1]

jmm
roy
floyd
evander
b hop are all better

first let me ask you, who will rank highest in the ATG list if were about to rank them all today? i mean pac and including the names you mentioned above?

an also, lets compare the achievements of the names mentioned above and then we'll see if youre lying

[JM1]

i think pacqiao is better than floyd regarding on achivement..floyd eat dust while his belt cant even make a dust of its own..but to put him on top 5 is questionable..

achievement wise of course pac is better than floyd. however, floyd is also the better boxer, more skilled overall though it doesnt mean hes greater than pac

and i agree that putting pac on top5 at this moment is very questionable

[burnerdafck]

i think i will rank pacqioa over floyd ... because the way paqioa beat two top 5 welters at the moment while floyd never been tested any of this fighters..though hes going to fight mosley..while big win over mosley is like cotto beat mosley..then pacqiao destroyed cotto...Then floyd start negotiation with ivan calderon for his belt to avoid pacquiao...

[daggum]

alfonso gomez has a better resume than both pac and may at the moment. gatti and castillo not to mention he was robbed against sergio mora. other possible contenders are zsolt erdei and billy dibb.

[baracuda]

alfonso gomez has a better resume than both pac and may at the moment. gatti and castillo not to mention he was robbed against sergio mora. other possible contenders are zsolt erdei and billy dibb.

alfonso gomez said pac is the greatest..........

[Pacquiao'd]

**** no, not even close. dude has a padded record

[burnerdafck]

floyd said he was a pacfans ... any one have a links?