If Calzaghe had not retired, where would you rank him?

[£-4-£]

If Calzaghe had not retired, where would you rank him in the P4P rankings?

I'd rank:

1) Pacman
2) Calzaghe
3) JMM
4) PBF (he'll go upto 2nd after he beats JMM)
5) Mosley
6) Cotto
7) Kessler
8) Donaire

cba with the rest


Know, I know Calzaghe beat past-prime Hopkins and RJJ but many people still consider Hopkins one of the best P4P, which has got to count for something - he's certainly the best LHW imo, which means Calzaghe would be the best LHW (well he did win the Ring LHW title of B-Hop after all)..

I think after the RJJ fight it was a good decision to retire, there were no more lucrative fights left for him. But had he not retired, he would have probably fought this summer and beat anybody put before him meaning in my mind he deserves no. 2 spot on the P4P list. After all he was undisputed SMW champion and has wins over Kessler (best active SMW), BHop (best LHW).

Just voicing my opinion.. What do you all think?

[daggum]

If Calzaghe had not retired, where would you rank him in the P4P rankings?

I'd rank:

1) Pacman
2) Calzaghe
3) JMM
4) PBF (he'll go upto 2nd after he beats JMM)
5) Mosley
6) Cotto
7) Kessler
8) Donaire

cba with the rest


Know, I know Calzaghe beat past-prime Hopkins and RJJ but many people still consider Hopkins one of the best P4P, which has got to count for something - he's certainly the best LHW imo, which means Calzaghe would be the best LHW (well he did win the Ring LHW title of B-Hop after all)..

I think after the RJJ fight it was a good decision to retire, there were no more lucrative fights left for him. But had he not retired, he would have probably fought this summer and beat anybody put before him meaning in my mind he deserves no. 2 spot on the P4P list. After all he was undisputed SMW champion and has wins over Kessler (best active SMW), BHop (best LHW).

Just voicing my opinion.. What do you all think?

calzaghe logic in full effect.

[The_Golden_Boi]

1st at the moment because like everyone says Pacquiao shouldn't be there so for me it would be first untill the Floyd fight!

[Kimbo Slice]

YoU gUyS aRe IdIoTs To ThInK pAc MaN iS p4P bEtTeR tHaN fLoYd, LoOk At PaC's ReCoRd CoMpArEd To FlOyDs ...NuFf SaId ChIlDrEn

[BEEHOP]

You actually have Joe rated higher than Floyd? Are you ******ed?

[Shattered Jaw]

YoU gUyS aRe IdIoTs To ThInK pAc MaN iS p4P bEtTeR tHaN fLoYd, LoOk At PaC's ReCoRd CoMpArEd To FlOyDs ...NuFf SaId ChIlDrEn

There are some seriously **** posts in this thread. The OP's was pretty crap but this is just a disgrace.

[_original_]

Well it would be immpossible to know, since we wouldn't know who he'd of foughten...B-Hop rematch and Chad Dawson maybe? Carl Froch?....who knows, Joe is gone and long forgotten.....almost

[Caesar]

don't agree with this ranking

[theghost#1]

He was #2 when he retired so unless Somebody beats him he would still be rated at #2 to this day.

[vercingetorix3]

There are some seriously **** posts in this thread. The OP's was pretty crap but this is just a disgrace.

If you think that's bad, look at the Posts per Day. The dude posts more often than most Viagra spambots.