Which of the BIG 3 have the better resume??

[TredKiller]

in talking Bhop, RJJ, and Toney.

there resume's in a nutshell (going by biggest names):

RJJ
Toney
Bhop
Ruiz

^^while roy doesnt have many HUGE wins, he beat the 2 guys who i am compareing, which says alot, there are other names, but these are the best wins.

Toney
Nunn
McCallum
Jirov
Holyfield

While McCallum was slightly past it, he was FAR from shot, and whil holyfield was in his late 30's, considering toney was a former MW, he knocked out the former champ, very hard to do.

Bhop
Trinidad
De La Hoya
Tarver
Winky
Pavlik

While trinidad was a former WW, he still had a MW belt, and was undefeated, and oscar is oscar lol.


i know there are other names that are good wins on there resumes, but i decided to stick to the HUGE wins. there are good wins like:
RJJ: Virgil Hill
Bhop: Glen Johnson
Toney: Reggie Johnson

but lets stick to the big wins, who had the better resume???

[Shattered Jaw]

All equally good I think... Bhop has the bigger names but a lot of those guys were coming up in weight so I can't decide between the three.

[-EX-]

Toss up between Roy and Bernard...prime for prime Roy would beat Bernard though

Better resume I might give and edge to Bernard but that could be cuz I'm a fan...

If Bernard beats Dawson he surpasses Roy IMO...

[IMDAZED]

^^while roy doesnt have many HUGE wins, he beat the 2 guys who i am compareing, which says alot, there are other names, but these are the best wins.

There's something tragically false in this statement.

[street bully]

Hopkins has the best resume. But Jones win over Toney was HUGE.

[TredKiller]

There's something tragically false in this statement.

obviously he has big wins, but not lot of HUGE memorable wins, know what i mean, you guys dont need to cretik every little thing i write, jus pick who you think, then explain.

[-EX-]

I could always argue for Roy that he started at 160 and won a title at heavyweight tho...

[catalinul]

Close between Jones and Toney bt I'd go with Jones.

Holyfield was actually 41 when he fought Toney.

[-EX-]

Close between Jones and Toney bt I'd go with Jones.

Holyfield was actually 41 when he fought Toney.

Toney over Hopkins???

[catalinul]

Toney over Hopkins???

Yes.

I always thought Hopkins's resume was overrated.