Which one of these fights do you feel the wrong man got the decision?

[Iceta]

Plus another thing I'm trying to use this thread for is a little bit of discussion about the Pacquiao-Cotto match up. You can use all three of these fights as a measuring stick for how they will match up with each other if you want to.

I do think it's wrong that it seems like Cotto and Pacquiao have no intentions of rematching these guys. The most likely rematch that would happen would be Cotto-Mosley because it still is somewhat marketable. But I don't think Cotto will ever tangle with Clottey again. And Pacquiao has said a couple of things about giving JMM a rubber match, but it seems like he has always been a hundred miles and running. He took half the payday to fight David Diaz. And I think it is unfair that JMM went into that fight as a champion, but yet Pacquiao went into the fight as the one with the rematch clause if he lost? That is just another example of how Manny got his way.

[flyest1]

All three fights were close and could have gone anyway


Floyd vs Castillo was close and not a robbery either. Every round Floyd won he won big. The only close rounds were 5,8, and 11. I bet the ones who claimed it was a robbery never even seen that fight. But he won the rematch easily

[Iceta]

Floyd vs. Castillo 1 was waay more of a robbery than Pac vs. Marquez

I probably should've added that into the poll along with Barrera-Marquez. I think JMM beat Barrera, but those judges that scored it that wide were on crack.

[Bhopreign]

pac definitely beat jmm and both times.

[RightCross94]

All were very close fights. But if i had to pick one that could have gone the other way, its marquez-pac 2

[badboypeenoy]

All three fights were close and could have gone anyway


Floyd vs Castillo was close and not a robbery either. Every round Floyd won he won big. The only close rounds were 5,8, and 11. I bet the ones who claimed it was a robbery never even seen that fight. But he won the rematch easily

Lederman scores it 115-111 Castillo

Lampley comments after the decision (and a lot of booing from the crowd) "not the fight we saw, definitely not the fight this crew saw"

Compubox numbers:
Castillo 506 thrown 203 landed powerpunches landed 173
Mayweather 448 thrown 157 landed powerpunches landed 66

Robbery.

[badboypeenoy]

pac definitely beat jmm and both times.

probably would have, if Marquez didn't kiss the canvas that often.

[Talisayen]

90% who watched the Cotto/Clottey thinks Clottey was robbed of a UD. The other 10% who thinks Cotto won were all Puerto Ricans.

[princemanspoper]

Cotto never hurt Clottey or Mosley once in those fights. Their were times of where he stopped Mosley in his tracks. But he never wobbled him except maybe a couple of times of all the times that he hit him.

fights are scored based upon a round by round system,Now take your head out of your **** hole

Lederman scores it 115-111 Castillo.

Lederman scored the fifth round for tito trinidad against de la hoya,What's your point?

Lampley comments after the decision (and a lot of booing from the crowd) "not the fight we saw, definitely not the fight this crew saw".

Lampley is a wife beater,What's your point?

Compubox numbers:
Castillo 506 thrown 203 landed powerpunches landed 173
Mayweather 448 thrown 157 landed powerpunches landed 66

Robbery.

compubox numbers are flawed and innacurate.The only way to score fights is by actually watching them in their entirety.Not listening to HBO and compubox

Then again,I'd never expect a manny pacquiao fanboy to know anything about boxing

[MANGLER]

All fair decisions.