Floyd Buckled Oscar, Pacquiao Never Hurt Him

[MaD RoBoT]

Thats what im trying to illustrate. People give PAQ the ATG title mainly based on those 2 wins, and compare them to the results of PBF fights against those same guys. But what they dont do is what you just did and thats acknowledge that the fights where under different circumstance and if situations were reversed then the outcomes may have been completely different. i.e. PBF could have KOd DLH and pac may have loss. So basically its pointless to say PAQ wins or Paq>>>>PBF base on those 2 fights.

wow, you really did just watched boxing 2 years ago

[sylvestersweet]

Maybe you just watched rounds 1-6 of the Pacquiao fight. Rounds 7 + 8 were a BEATDOWN.

[rommel357]

Mayweather didn't get a SD, it was a U.D.

Nope. Mayweather got a SD. I just double checked in The Ring Mag website.

http://www.ringtv.com/gallery/12/oscar_de_la_hoya_vs_floyd_mayweather_jr_may_5_2007/#180

[tesla_power]

Thats what im trying to illustrate. People give PAQ the ATG title mainly based on those 2 wins, and compare them to the results of PBF fights against those same guys. But what they dont do is what you just did and thats acknowledge that the fights where under different circumstance and if situations were reversed then the outcomes may have been completely different. i.e. PBF could have KOd DLH and pac may have loss. So basically its pointless to say PAQ wins or Paq>>>>PBF base on those 2 fights.

Non-pacnuthuggers would argue that he is considered ATG material based on wins against the 3 Mex-amigos. DLH is a high risk but extremely high reward fight. Hatton is for the history-making distiction of 4 lineal champion.

You must take account the risks involved. You are right that different circumstances may lead to different outcomes but the risk for pac in taking those fights is greater than the risk taken by pbf. And to come out the way he did in those 2 fights is very impressive.

Basically, pac did extremely well considering his inherent weakness.

Also, talent-wise, pbf >> pac. But accomplishment-wise, pac is already greater than pbf.

[nujabes77]

floyd got a split, pac whooped that ass... now go have a cup of sdfu

[Manny Duckman]

Floyd fought a 165 pound Oscar, while Pacman fought a 147 Oscar. Pacman also outweighed Oscar

[Kalion]

wow, you really did just watched boxing 2 years ago

2 yrs ago who was P4P #1 and who had a resume between Pac and Floyd?

[sandyvahra]

2 yrs ago who was P4P #1 and who had a resume between Pac and Floyd?

Seriously your arguments are weak. Were not living in 2 years ago. Were living today, and today Pacman is the face of the sport. Pac's resume ****s on PBFs...again just go refer to older polls no need to regurgitate the same garbage spewed by other haters/huggers.

[MaD RoBoT]

2 yrs ago who was P4P #1 and who had a resume between Pac and Floyd?

take away both DLH & Hatton in their resume Pac still trumps Floyd

Wake up boy

[Kalion]

Seriously your arguments are weak. Were not living in 2 years ago. Were living today, and today Pacman is the face of the sport. Pac's resume ****s on PBFs...again just go refer to older polls no need to regurgitate the same garbage spewed by other haters/huggers.

The only thing that has change between pac and floyd in the last 2 years are his 2 wins over same 2 guys PBF beat before he took his vacation. Im not hating on Pac, If your a true boxing fan you should never hate any fighter. All im saying is pac got double the credit PBF got for beating 2 guys under very different circumstances.Those 2 wins are the one of the key reasons peple use to prove PAQs greatness. Try to think rationally about what im saying before you throw up your defenses to protect your favorite fighter.