Better Chin... Oscar, Ricky or Cotto?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Oscar definitely.

Ricky had a very good chin but it declined through the years.

Cotto had a suspect chin at 140 but it got better moving up.

[rizkybizness]

Oscar definitely.

Ricky had a very good chin but it declined through the years.

Cotto had a suspect chin at 140 but it got better moving up.

very reasonable, objective post

[Dirk Diggler UK]

very reasonable, objective post

You sound surprised?

[rizkybizness]

You sound surprised?

i was expecting you to say something like "hatton's chin was iron in his prime" or something along those lines

green k for you, sir

[Talisayen]

Dela Hoya and Penalosa

[Bushbaby]

Oscars 2 ko losses,1 by body shot,the other by quitting,besides that he hasnt been rocked or dropped more than 3 times I wan't to say,Ike,Sweet Pea and someone else in 1 of his first fights!!

Cotto has been rocked and dropped plenty times,even against feather fisted Demarcus Corely,but u can't question his heart!!

Ricky been stopped 2 times by chinchecks!!

[Dan...]

Poll results say it all.

Oscar and it isn't even remotely close.

[El Chicano]

Poll results say it all.

Oscar and it isn't even remotely close.

Very well put. I think this should be the end of this discussion, now on to my next thread....

[hookoutofhell]

hatton was a beast on the tszyu night and tszty was one of the p4p hardest punchers at the time but ricky just ate his shots and kept on coming. however so far hes been wobbles by the likes of lazcano, collazo and of course KO'd by pacman and floyd (both of whom are smaller than him). therefore anyone who thinks that he has a better chin that cotto or DLH needs their head looked at.

cotto might have been wobbled once or twice but that was down at 140 and because of that i think he should be forgiven. at 147 he has taken flush shots from SSM, judah, margarito and clottey.

imo DLH has the best chin, hopkins only managed to KO him by going to the body and DLH has taken shots from mayorga, tito, SSM, ike, vargas and hopkins. all guys who are either powerful punchers or bigger than him. iv excused cotto for the few wobbles he had at 140 because he had to cut the weight but even when DLH had to cut alot of weight to make 147 (for pacman) he was still not hurt during the course of the bout.

[713832281]

come on OP, you cannot compare fattons and cottos chin to oscar. oscar hands down.