Pac beats Cotto hes GOAT material

[$partacus]

No fighter will ever be greater than Robinson and Ali. NONE they've got it locked down forever.

[VirusTI]

If RJJ didnt become GOAT, pac sure as hell isnt.

[street bully]

Hell no. No one in this generation can touch SRR, ALi, and Armstrong. No way no how.

[billionaire]

anybody that gets beat by washed up erik morales who lost 5 of his last 6 fights can never be GOAT........

[blind4]

he is not going to win but if does props for Manny

[shadeyfizzle]

Fighters today also don't fight the ridiculous number of fights fighters used to. It's just impossible for a fighter today to have 6 fights against a Jake Lamotta, or separate trilogies against two fighters like Ali did with Norton and Frazier.

We can't compare them very well as far as impressive records because of that.

Muhammad Ali is 2nd or 3rd in everyone's GOAT list.
Professional record: 56wins 5losses 0draws

Manny Pacquiao
Professional record: 49wins 3losses 2draws

He'll only be 6 fights off after the Cotto fight.

Pacquiao already has a trilogy with Morales, and a possible trilogy with Marquez and Mayweather on the horizon.

Surely by the time its all said and done if Pacquiao's not in the running at all for GOAT conversations it'll be a crime against boxing.

[shadeyfizzle]

anybody that gets beat by washed up erik morales who lost 5 of his last 6 fights can never be GOAT........

I love how every floyd stan has a gif or sig of mayweather's padwork like it's some great athletic feat. Looks pretty but anyone who's ever boxed before knows its nothing more than grown man patty cake.

[Bhopreign]

Hes seriously got a stacked resume

Chatchai Sasakul for WBC flyweight- Won by TKO in the 4th round, good win

Reynante Jamili for the WBC super Bantamweight- Won by TKO in the 2nd round, impressive as the guy had 41 wins

Seung-Kon Chae ,Nedal Hussein and Emmanuel Lucero all unbeaten super bantamweights Manny TKO'd for Superbantam weight titles (WBC and IBF)

Marco Antonio Barerra Went up to featherweight and TKO'd an ATG legend of the ring (no title)

Erik Morales Another featherweight ATG TKO'd by manny, then KO'd in the 3rd in the rematch

Jorge Solis Unbeaten challenger for the WBC super featherweight K.O' d in the 8th

Marco Antonio Barerra This time at Super feather, wide UD

Juan Manuel Marquez One of the most deadly mexicans, future and current P4P no 2 (only second to manny)

Oscar De La Hoya 8th division climb since flyweight, destroyed multi title holder in both welter and middle in TKO

Ricky Hatton Former undisputed LWW champion, came off a good win against paul malignaggi, beat by KO in round 2

Manny has beaten some of the best fighters of our generation by K.O, how can that not be GOAT material?

how does beating cotto do that for him.

[shadeyfizzle]

how does beating cotto do that for him.

I suppose he's assuming Pacquiao becomes the 1st 7 division title holder which may or may not be on the line.

[DonTaseMeBrah]

he's a all time great already. be happy with that.

only way he gets by robinson (impossible really) is if he fought & beat cotto, mosley, paul williams, mr. counterfeit cash, margarito at 147.

thats after he went back down to 135 got some belts & defended them & beat marquez, valero, guzman, diaz,

& then went to 140 got some belts & defend them & beat bradley,campbell, khan, maidana, & holt.

then we can start the argument.

until then,

be happy (i know he is) that he is an all time great first ballot hall of famer top 20-30 all time great.