When Cotto Beats Pac, P4P #1?

[JM1]

I actually think people would have Floyd over him since he will have beaten JMM by that time. I also see Mosley being over him despite the head to head loss which would be strange. Maybe Williams also but thats about it or atleast that I can think of. Even though people think that Margarito cheated, it still happened and people cant get that out of there head. Then you add to that he just doesnt look the same. Ofcourse he would have to look good to beat Pac but I just dont think it would be enough considering how he's recently looked. I do think alot of writers would have him #1 though

floyd wont get credit for beating a lightweight champ and how can williams outrank cotto in the p4p list specially when cotto beats pac?

[onedream722]

floyd wont get credit for beating a lightweight champ and how can williams outrank cotto in the p4p list specially when cotto beats pac?

yeah cotto would be ahead of williams...but williams will be up there with a win against sergei dzindziruk..and he'll move up again if rafa and izzy fight for the fourth time with the loser dropping out of the top 10

[Mersey]

Personally, I don't think Cotto is good enough or will be good enough to be p4p#1.

[BOOMbip]

Who knows what the Golden boy run Ring magazine will do...

Cotto beats the top 3 WW in the world and drops 2 spots...but he gets on the list for beating Micheal Jennings...I don't understand how they make there list...but it seems odd at best.

[JM1]

yeah cotto would be ahead of williams...but williams will be up there with a win against sergei dzindziruk..and he'll move up again if rafa and izzy fight for the fourth time with the loser dropping out of the top 10

no doubt that williams will be in the p4p list its just that he wont outrank cotto specially if cotto was able to beat pac

[nosfer]

then who is going to be P4P#1 if cotto defeats pac?

JMM?

[[ILLMatic]]

then who is going to be P4P#1 if cotto defeats pac?

JMM?

If He Beats PBF. Logically He Should

[Mayweather Sr]

When Tarver beats Jones, did he become #1?

Was Tarver in the top 10 P4P ratings when he beat Jones jr? No. Cotto is number 8 right now so a win over Pacquiao would most definetly give him him the 1# or close to it.

[KittenFlaps]

If JMM beats Mayweather and Pac beats Cotto who is #1?

[rob6465]

Probably not, some pac fans will still complain or want pacman at #1.