Would CALZAGHE be TOP 10 ATG if he would be AMERICAN? POLL

[Deja_Vous]

dude, hopkins isn't even top 10 atg, how the **** is calz gonna get there??

Looks like the Manfredo footage ran all the Brits off.

[AssasinKing]

Im a huge calzaghe fan but i gotta say no on this....

He is an amazing fighter...and i think he would of given ANY SMW trouble.... but i also believe the level of competition is what makes the best ATG's....and unlucky for cals....he had a pretty **** division....if he was in an era with great fighters im sure he would of been considered...especially if he was american....they wldnt stop talkin bout him.....Like they do with P.Will

[UnDeniable]

it would help his case a lot no doubt

He has no case

[Deja_Vous]

Im a huge calzaghe fan but i gotta say no on this....

He is an amazing fighter...and i think he would of given ANY SMW trouble.... but i also believe the level of competition is what makes the best ATG's....and unlucky for cals....he had a pretty **** division....if he was in an era with great fighters im sure he would of been considered...especially if he was american....they wldnt stop talkin bout him.....Like they do with P.Will

Joe was not an amazing fighter..STOP IT..!!

You are too easilly impressed for your own good.

[AssasinKing]

Joe was not an amazing fighter..STOP IT..!!

You are too easilly impressed for your own good.

Every post you make is near enough bull****.....

He WAS an amazing fighter, too easilly impressed? name me other people i say are "amazing fighters" besides pacquiao.... Hes done enough to be an ATG....You dont go undefeated like that in your career and he did have some fkin hard fights...people say B-hop is past it...but how long ago was calzaghe past it? just because he still does his best and looks great...he wasnt in his prime either...

The jones fight wasnt exactly good, but it was something i think joe needed to do at the end of his career n good on him...

[Deja_Vous]

Every post you make is near enough bull****.....

He WAS an amazing fighter, too easilly impressed? name me other people i say are "amazing fighters" besides pacquiao.... Hes done enough to be an ATG....You dont go undefeated like that in your career and he did have some fkin hard fights...people say B-hop is past it...but how long ago was calzaghe past it? just because he still does his best and looks great...he wasnt in his prime either...

The jones fight wasnt exactly good, but it was something i think joe needed to do at the end of his career n good on him...

You know damn well Joe wasn't amazing.

Amazingly average.

[Mr.Fantastic]

You know damn well Joe wasn't amazing.

Amazingly average.

That beat two ATGs .

[daggum]

Every post you make is near enough bull****.....

He WAS an amazing fighter, too easilly impressed? name me other people i say are "amazing fighters" besides pacquiao.... Hes done enough to be an ATG....You dont go undefeated like that in your career and he did have some fkin hard fights...people say B-hop is past it...but how long ago was calzaghe past it? just because he still does his best and looks great...he wasnt in his prime either...

The jones fight wasnt exactly good, but it was something i think joe needed to do at the end of his career n good on him...

he needed to beat up a shot fighter live on ppv so he could make an easy paycheck while avoiding other top fighters?

[Mr.Fantastic]

he needed to beat up a shot fighter live on ppv so he could make an easy paycheck while avoiding other top fighters?

What other top fighters are these?? Dawson?? Hopkins is ducking him too, I don't hear **** from peeps on that ****. Double standards.

[AssasinKing]

he needed to beat up a shot fighter live on ppv so he could make an easy paycheck while avoiding other top fighters?

Its the last fight of his career....why take on a young person who wont even add to his legacy or do anything for himself?

I saw plenty of people still sayin calzaghe was gonna lose...he stil proved them wrong...n why no get a huge paycheck on you last fight? he deserved it, would you tell pacquiao to fight a **** last fight with no purse in it for him....exactly..

N the only "top fighters" you could be talkin about are dawson...your just tryin 2 make it sound worse