So...what do ya'll consider ATG?

[-EX-]

I hate this ****. I dunno how cats place fighters unless they keep their personal list saved or sumthin.

Well everything's hypothetical...idk anyone who has an actual list.

Kinda hard to do...I never seen Henry Armstrong fight

I'm jus askin how far along wud u go number wise for sum1 to be ATG

[Jayseen]

I consider an all time great someone who has faced the best opposition and has proven to be dominant in his weight class and one of the best fighters p4p in the world. Someone who has greats skills and shows to be a tough challenge and a huge risk for anyone. (Sorry i'm drunk)

[WhoreUs]

In your mind is ATG...top 20 or 25? top 30? top 50? 40?

Well...?

Poll to come...

one of the best (can be argued as the #1 or 2 guy) in his division (except super middleweight and cruiserweight since those are new)

[bojangles1987]

An all-time great for me is a guy who is remembered in their era because of their accomplishments. I can't really put a number as far as rank.

Like the past couple decades, all-time greats would be:

Roy Jones
Bernard Hopkins
Pernell Whitaker
Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Floyd Mayweather
Lennox Lewis
Joe Calzaghe
Shane Mosley
Manny Pacquiao
Erik Morales
Marco Antonio Barrera

Just some examples. These are all guys that in the future when describing the 90's and 00's, we will be talking about.

[AssasinKing]

That's easy...

Win % is greater or equal to 95 %
Popularity is equal to 100%
Number of fights exceeds 50
Win 3 belt(s) in two different weight classes
P4P ranking equals #1
Win an ESPN Wednesday Night Fight
Win an ESPN Friday Night Fight
Win a PPV Fight
Defend title(s) at least 8 times

I LOL'd!!!! But thats G.O.A.T not ATG :P

I got 10 fights before i get GOAT :/ stil...undefeated online so far..only had like 10 fights tho

[D-MiZe]

An all-time great for me is a guy who is remembered in their era because of their accomplishments. I can't really put a number as far as rank.

Like the past couple decades, all-time greats would be:

Roy Jones
Bernard Hopkins
Pernell Whitaker
Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Floyd Mayweather
Lennox Lewis
Joe Calzaghe
Shane Mosley
Manny Pacquiao
Erik Morales
Marco Antonio Barrera

Just some examples. These are all guys that in the future when describing the 90's and 00's, we will be talking about.

Why Morales?

[bojangles1987]

Why Morales?

I can't put Barrera or Pacquiao without Morales.

[D-MiZe]

I can't put Barrera or Pacquiao without Morales.

Pacman qualifies without Morales tbh, he's got wins over;

Hatton
Marquez
MAB x2
Diaz
DLH

[yeks]

Why Morales?

morales is a 3 division champion.. only few can do that..
how people really have a short memory..
he was one of the best boxer ever laced at 122..