vic should not be taken out of the p4p ranks

[larry x]

why the **** are ya'll so critical of a fighter after they lose???????

[Konstantin]

He was in the bottom half and with a loss he is taken out. I would like to know the fighters who have remained after losses.

Never had him in my lb4lb... He was just spanked by some random ass titlist. Made to look like an amature, exactly what Donaire did to him. A win over Mijares was good, but Arce is just a name, like Gatti.

[Spirit]

He was in the bottom half and with a loss he is taken out. I would like to know the fighters who have remained after losses.

Correct

Aside from that I never saw Vic as a top p4p fighter. Theres a significant difference between him and other top p4p fighters and that is that they actually have solid boxing skills. Vic has decent boxing skills with a lot of power. Last night he experienced how far power will get a boxer once he moves up

[BattlingNelson]

Vic isn't on boxingscene's p4p list:

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/view.php?pg=pound

[larry x]

so this is why boxers are safety first..cause ******* fans abandon them if they lose any damn way..id say **** the fans too

[-Mbandit-]

He was in the bottom half and with a loss he is taken out. I would like to know the fighters who have remained after losses.

Rafael Marquez after he lost to Vasquez, in their third fight.

[F l i c k e r]

i dont understand some people on here..ya'll **** on fighters for not taking risk..then vic jumps to his third division loses and now he's overated???wtf???he still has 3 belts ..damn this is what i mean by damned if a fighter does and damned if he doesnt...vic is a top p4p fighter he is a 2 division champ and is fearless...some people are never satisfied....

well, he got ktfo by Nonito. Then moves up, beats D class opponents, then loses to the bantamweight champ who isn't the undisputed champion. Seems like he should be knocked out of the top 10 if you ask me.

[AntDawg]

so this is why boxers are safety first..cause ******* fans abandon them if they lose any damn way..id say **** the fans too

I was never a fan to begin with. Dude just fights dumb imo from what I have seen from him anyway.

[Khalid X]

i dont understand some people on here..ya'll **** on fighters for not taking risk..then vic jumps to his third division loses and now he's overated???wtf???he still has 3 belts ..damn this is what i mean by damned if a fighter does and damned if he doesnt...vic is a top p4p fighter he is a 2 division champ and is fearless...some people are never satisfied....

Co-mutha-****in sign. If it wasnt for Bull**** ass fans and boxing analyst boxing would be so much better. Boxers know people will right them off quick if they loose a fight, hence boxers taken less risk and stoping to sport from being great like it once was.

[Iceta]

I usually don't kick dirt on a fighter when they lose. That's not my style. I just don't think that Vic was as good as a lot of other people hyped him up to be. Another thing I couldn't stand about him was the fact that he was the one who got these title shots instead of Nonito Donaire, and when he made it big he wasn't willing to entertain the thought of avenging his defeat to him. Shaw just kicked Donaire to the curb. After Margarito beat Cotto, I remember when a lot of other posters were expecting him to avenge his defeat to Paul Williams. If you are not willing to do it, then you don't belong in the P4P list.