German p4p list. WTF???????

[keepthemhandsup]

German tabloid Bild today made a p4p list. It's as unbiased as it gets:

1: Manny Pacquiao
2: Wladimir Klitschko
3: Vitali Klitschko
4: Arthur Abraham
5: Mikkel Kessler
6: Felix Sturm
7: Shane Mosley
8: Chad Dawson
9: Juan Manuel Marquez
10: Juan Manuel Lopez

Thoughts????

i aggre with this list 100%.......


felix strum fought de la hoya

kessler fought calzhage and mundine who we already know fought nothing but cab driviers.....which makes them a ATG

pacquiao should be replaced with abraham who never fought outside of gremnary.......

[#1Assassin]

mikkel kessler p4p

[Dubious-Dutch]

Although biased towards known fighters in Germany I think there is a tendency on US sites to underrate the klit's quite a bit.

Yea, but Bat would you ever see a list like this?

1)Manny Pacman
2)Bernard Hopkins
3)Shane Mosley
4)Chad Dawson
5)Kelly pavlik
6)JMM
7)Vasquez
8)Margarito
9)Gamboa
10)Victor Ortiz

[keepthemhandsup]

Yea, but Bat would you ever see a list like this?

1)Manny Pacman
2)Bernard Hopkins
3)Shane Mosley
4)Chad Dawson
5)Kelly pavlik
6)JMM
7)Vasquez
8)Margarito
9)Gamboa
10)Victor Ortiz

ortiz should be number 2...he fought a prime maidana and didn't quit when the going got tough

[Dubious-Dutch]

ortiz should be number 2...he fought a prime maidana and didn't quit when the going got tough

He just moved up a couple notches after that thrilling performance.

[Cotto Rules]

1)Margarito
2) Julio Cesar Chavez JR.
3) Junior Witter
4)Ricky Hatton
5)Brahim Asloum
6)Hasim Rahman
7) Nicolay Valuev
8) Erislany Lara
9) Carlos Baldomir
10) Ruslan Chagaev.

That's my Pound For Pound list.

[Cotto Rules]

1)Margarito
2) Julio Cesar Chavez JR.
3) Junior Witter
4)Ricky Hatton
5)Brahim Asloum
6)Hasim Rahman
7) Nicolay Valuev
8) Erislany Lara
9) Carlos Baldomir
10) Ruslan Chagaev.

That's my Pound For Pound list.

[LA BAD BOY]

German tabloid Bild today made a p4p list. It's as unbiased as it gets:

1: Manny Pacquiao
2: Wladimir Klitschko
3: Vitali Klitschko
4: Arthur Abraham
5: Mikkel Kessler
6: Felix Sturm
7: Shane Mosley
8: Chad Dawson
9: Juan Manuel Marquez
10: Juan Manuel Lopez

Thoughts????

Bwahhahahahaha FELIX STURM!!!
They are INSANE!!!
That guy got smashed two times against Javier Castilleo

[keepthemhandsup]

1)Margarito
2) Julio Cesar Chavez JR.
3) Junior Witter
4)Ricky Hatton
5)Brahim Asloum
6)Hasim Rahman
7) Nicolay Valuev
8) Erislany Lara
9) Carlos Baldomir
10) Ruslan Chagaev.

That's my Pound For Pound list.

why u got chavez jr higher than carlos freaking baldomir. baldomir fought a prime mayweather and was giving him his money worth in that fight



because mayweather had an easy payday that day

[BattlingNelson]

Yea, but Bat would you ever see a list like this?

1)Manny Pacman
2)Bernard Hopkins
3)Shane Mosley
4)Chad Dawson
5)Kelly pavlik
6)JMM
7)Vasquez
8)Margarito
9)Gamboa
10)Victor Ortiz

Lol. That's a bad one. Of course compiling a p4p list is always debateable.

Where did you get that?