Ring magazine Pound for pound? AGREE?

[ИATAS]

It's not a bad list. I think P-Will belongs on there though. If I made one it would look something like this although my feelings might change soon

Pacquiao
Marquez
Hopkins
Shane Mosley
Paul Williams
Darchinyan
Miguel Cotto
Vazquez
Donaire
Caballero

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

it's not a bad list. I think p-will belongs on there though. If i made one it would look something like this although my feelings might change soon

pacquiao
marquez
hopkins
shane mosley
paul williams
darchinyan
miguel cotto
vazquez
donaire
caballero

wtf????????/

[Mr.Fantastic]

wtf????????/

PW can't even defend a belt right. What's so P4P about that??

[The_Demon]

First of all He is the only one who gave pacquiao all he could handle as of recent . 2nd his first appearance at lighweight he knocks Casamayor out. then knocks out a Young lion name Juan Diaz at 35 years old. Best boxer skill wise up there with FMJ.

You will see when cotto goes down in Nov. how tough JMM is to go 24 rounds with the pacman and only lose by 1 point with both fight combined

if you combine both fights with all judges marquez won 38-34 or something like that-he gave pac hell and is a great fighter,duno why he has got these haters

[KittenFlaps]

cause cotto got spanked by margo and mosley spanked margo.

So Foreman > Ali then....

That logic is what makes these silly P4P lists so wrong.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

PW can't even defend a belt right. What's so P4P about that??

I dont Mind Paull at 10, because thats like a open spot. But #5? **** now. Like you said, he has not even had a succesfull title defense.

Donaire(has fought only bums, besides Darchinyan)

And cabllerohas not beat anyone of notice, to be rank up there!!!!!

[KittenFlaps]

Putting Paul Williams on that list and not putting Wlad on that list would be the biggest travesty in sports history.

[araindon]

The reason Klitschko can't get into the list is because P4P rankings aren't meant to have heavyweights! The list was created to give weight classes below Heavyweight a chance to shine and some recognition because back in the day, Heavyweight boxing was the pinnacle of the sport...thats why Vlad isn't on the list, thats why Lewis wasn't on the list, thats why Tyson was never P4P #1 and thats why Muhammad Ali wasn't either.

[ИATAS]

I dont Mind Paull at 10, because thats like a open spot. But #5? **** now. Like you said, he has not even had a succesfull title defense.

After #1, I really don't care you can place them just about anywhere.

Donaire(has fought only bums, besides Darchinyan)

Beating the crap out of Darchinyan is not to be overlooked like it's nothing. If Darchinyan is ranked top ten, and Donaire beat the crap out of him, and has beat the crap out of pretty much everyone else since, then yeah, he should be top 10.

And cabllerohas not beat anyone of notice, to be rank up there!!!!!

He's there mainly because of his annihilation of another previously top 10 ranked fighter, in Steve Molitor.

Let me ask you, who should be in the top ten in place of Caballero & Donaire? Answer me that and make a case for another fighter...

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

After #1, I really don't care you can place them just about anywhere.



Beating the crap out of Darchinyan is not to be overlooked like it's nothing. If Darchinyan is ranked top ten, and Donaire beat the crap out of him, and has beat the crap out of pretty much everyone else since, then yeah, he should be top 10.



He's there mainly because of his annihilation of another previously top 10 ranked fighter, in Steve Molitor.

Let me ask you, who should be in the top ten in place of Caballero & Donaire? Answer me that and make a case for another fighter...

1. Ok If you dont care, fair enough.

2.Nope it doesnt work that way. Donaire have only beat Darchinyan, when Darchinyan was barely a champ on the rise, he wasnt even close to top 10-p4P status. Untill Donaire figths somebody with a pulse he aint deserving of a P4P ranking!!!!!

3. And? Who the **** was Molitor? He was a protected Canadien Bum. Cablleros best win is a UD win against De Leon, whom Juanma KTFO in 1 round. And Caballero, got whoop in his last fight. He got lit up by Mathebula, and they robbed the African guy. Even the Panamien Annources said so!!!

4.John and calderon!!!!!!!!