the only 4 times heavyweight champ

[money4life]

Ali

Louis

Marciano

Holmes

Holyfield

[NakiFan]

I would put him in the top 3 no question imo

[Obama]

I rate him in the top 10. p4p, among these 10 Heavyweights, I'd rate him in the top 5.

[MANGLER]

I don't like these ATG threads usually, cuz it's too ****in hard to place guys precisely unless you got your personal lists right in front of you. But I do think Holy is 1 of the gr8est HW's, just not sure where exactly he'd be.

[NakiFan]

Well which of the "great Heavyweights" beats him prime 4 prime? I have only Ali, and Lewis JUST in a very hard fight, i think he takes most others

[money4life]

Holyfield beat tyson, foreman, holmes who are all in the top 10. what other heavyweight has done that?

[money4life]

he also beat lennox

[BattlingNelson]

Well which of the "great Heavyweights" beats him prime 4 prime? I have only Ali, and Lewis JUST in a very hard fight, i think he takes most others

P4p has nothing to do with who you'll beat in a head-to-head match-up. It's about what have you actually done at the weight and who have you beaten and lost to.

If it was about head-to-head in fantasy match-ups then Vitali Klitschko cracks the top 10 easily.

7 of evanders 10 losses came after age 37, and dont go "oh vitali is 37" because you know age means ****, people were saying evander needed to retire back in like '96

Lol. Please educate us regarding which fights to disregard regarding Holyfield and Tyson.

This could be entertaining........

[Oasis_Lad]

Definitely top 10, just not top 5.

[knn]

how can you not rank this guy in the top 5 heavy of all time?

the only 4 times heavyweight champ

You reward losing/retiring while you punish STAYING DOMINANTLY AT THE TOP.

If a guy loses 20x his title and wins it 20x back he would be 20times world champion in your book. Ridiculous.

Evan Fields heavyweight record right now is 24wins-10losses.

His performance against Valuev was a disgrace for boxing: Running away for 12 rounds and throwing 3 featherfist punches per round.

Moreover he is one of the most lazy "champs" ever. Had only 1.8 heavyweight fights per year in his career.