Better resume: Spinks or Judah?

[Walt Liquor]

The resumes are close but Spinks showing v Jermaine Taylor was basically a draw v an elite fighter. Zab gets merked everytime he steps up to an elite fighter. I give zab credit for fighting everyone, but he is a gatekeeper. When spinks spanked mayorga, everyone thought mayorga was a total beast.

[warp1432]

I thought Taylor clearly beat Spinks, but I'm going with Spinks in the poll. Judah is a better fighter though head to head.

[dde91]

The resumes are close but Spinks showing v Jermaine Taylor was basically a draw v an elite fighter. Zab gets merked everytime he steps up to an elite fighter. I give zab credit for fighting everyone, but he is a gatekeeper. When spinks spanked mayorga, everyone thought mayorga was a total beast.

hahaha Spinks didn't SPANK mayorga. He Ran more then Hitting.

[Walt Liquor]

I thought Taylor clearly beat Spinks, but I'm going with Spinks in the poll. Judah is a better fighter though head to head.

Jermain had his patented late fight fade.

[Walt Liquor]

hahaha Spinks didn't SPANK mayorga. He Ran more then Hitting.

Can u say boxing clinic? By spanked, I meant on the scorecards.

[MANGLER]

I'd give Zab an edge here.

[1SILVA]

Two washed up has beens who beat each other. They can both go away, no one cares about these bums

[JACK D. RIPPER]

Spinks- Mayorga, Judah, Karmazin, Latimore, Pineda

Judah- Corley, Ward, young Witter, Pineda, Spinks

Both guys titlists in 2 different weightclasses.

Spinks by a hair. I just think he shows more heart than Judah in general. Though Judah impressed me against Cotto, only to proceed to **** it all up against Clottey.

If I could, I'd give Judah red kaye.

[BennyST]

Pretty close really. Both guys have good, solid resumes and have beaten their fair share of good champions. Judah has faced much greater competition over the whole course of his career, but lost his biggest fights.

Nonetheless, they have both beaten the good champions they fought. Yeah, about even.

[-EX-]

Bump for further discussion...