Who ranks higher on the ATG list CURRENTLY--Floyd Mayweather Jr. or Oscar De La Hoya

[#1Assassin]

odlh > sweetpea/chaversr/quartey

chavez - past his best
quartey - bad decision
sweet pea - past his best and a bad decision

[blind4]

mayweather but he is not a GOAT, he is just a Great boxer for now

[Pullcounter]

There seems to be more in favor of De La Hoya recently. I want to see what the majority thinks.

Vote and discuss.

floyd won all his big fights.... dlh didn't

[Ravishing]

Floyd's the more impressive fighter no doubt, but Oscar's resume win or lose speaks for itself. He'll be remembered for fighting the best guys and being an ambassador for the sport.

I can't speak on how high Floyd is on an ATG list (which is really all opinionated anyway), but I would understand how some would place Oscar over him and vice versa, depends how you look at it (it's not just based on wins solely and more on who you fought in your time).

Floyd IMO hasn't lived up to his potential since he reached the top. Let's see what he does in the next year or 2.

[larry x]

floyd...oscar may have fought the better fighters but...he lost to most of them..floyd has beaten everyone he's fought..including oscar

[Doctor_Tenma]

im not a fan of eighter fighter, but DLHs record in big fights is just a bit too weak.. and the crazy part is he still ducked fighters, like winky and vernon.

floyd takes it.

People don't mention that, how DLH didn't fight Winky or Forrest. I agree, DLH lost most of his big fights. In my opnion though, DLH got robbed (Tito, SSM II) and got gifts (Strum, Ike, Whitaker).

[7punchcombo]

There seems to be more in favor of De La Hoya recently. I want to see what the majority thinks.

Vote and discuss.

De la hoya. Until FLoyd faces Mosley Cotto and Margarito he doesnt even come close to making it

[Ravishing]

People don't mention that, how DLH didn't fight Winky or Forrest. I agree, DLH lost most of his big fights. In my opnion though, DLH got robbed (Tito, SSM II) and got gifts (Strum, Ike, Whitaker).

But at that point, that was like asking Floyd to fight Paul Williams now. Does anyone believe that'll ever happen? I don't.

He still fought dangerous guys, Winky and Vernon simply wasn't a smart business move for Oscar at that point of his career (154-160lbs).

[OZ1986]

Mayweather EASY. More impressive victories- this is a fact.

End of the day people go on about Oscars resume including Floyd, BHop, Mosley and Pacquiao on it. He LOST to them all. I could get in the ring with the best fighters in the world and get torn up, would that make me a great fighter?

Who the **** has Floyd beat?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I don't get it, he has never been in a war! Gatti? Old DLH? Lost to an old Castillo! Hatton is a bum from hell! He's a ***** that runs! When he gets beat it is going to be funny, yet sad. Manny will tear him a new ahole and so would Cotto! Please wake up.

[Luis12]

mayweather but he is not a GOAT, he is just a Great boxer for now

agreed

floyd won all his big fights.... dlh didn't

which fights??

floyd...oscar may have fought the better fighters but...he lost to most of them..floyd has beaten everyone he's fought..including oscar

which fights??

De la hoya. Until FLoyd faces Mosley Cotto and Margarito he doesnt even come close to making it

agreed

beating gatti, bruseles, hatton and marquez doesn't put u above DLH