Where would you rank Haye p4p if he beat both Klitschkos

[street bully]

P4P ranking are bias against HW's I think the only HW to be P4P number one during their time were Ali and Tyson.

[DrewWoodside]

Bull**** argument.

Say 1 guy beats everyone from number 11 down to 20, all by dominant KO/TKO.

You saying that guy wouldn't be ranked in the Top 10 P4P?

Your point was in response to Larry who said neither Klit is P4P. So the reality of the situation is that your response was irrelevant to Larry's. However, in answer to your question. Yes if a fighter beat 10 opponents ranked 11-20, he would likely earn a top 10 position.

[Hitman932]

If he beat both Klitschko's he would easily be in the top-10.

But lets be honest, he is never going to beat one of them much less both.

We may as well be asking where Chad Dawson would be if he beat both Klitschkos.

[DrewWoodside]

If he beat both Klitschko's he would easily be in the top-10.

But lets be honest, he is never going to beat one of them much less both.

We may as well be asking where Chad Dawson would be if he beat both Klitschkos.

Who knows. he might do it.. The way things are going though it's hard to imagine the fights ever getting made.

[-----------]

Your point was in response to Larry who said neither Klit is P4P. So the reality of the situation is that your response was irrelevant to Larry's. However, in answer to your question. Yes if a fighter beat 10 opponents ranked 11-20, he would likely earn a top 10 position.

My response was that the argument he's using was bull****.

Why can't you see that, my posts have nothing to do with Wlad/Vitali/Haye, i'm not discussing that, i'm discussing the argument he's trying to use.

It's like trying to teach a Monkey how to write talking to you.

[larry x]

yea, and LOL to the division, and thus lack of good opposition.

And LOL to the way he wins, Doesn't exactly BLAST them out of there does he.

yea he wins by ko 46 out of 52 times and..this is the same division you said can make haye p4p????im lost here

[Jim Jeffries]

Undisputed CW champ and Undisputed HW champ? Beating two guys much bigger than him to do it at HW? And he doesn't warrant consideration for top 10? What a garbage list.

[Hitman932]

Who knows. he might do it.. The way things are going though it's hard to imagine the fights ever getting made.

Honestly, I would stake my house, car and kidneys at 10-1 odds that Haye doesn't beat both Klitschkos in his career.

As it is I am pissed off because I had a $4000 bet on Wlad over Haye at great odds and I was counting on that money for an awesome vacation.

[roe]

The way I see this pound for pound thing anyway is that it can be ranked (fairly) on either of achievement or ability (I guess most people's lists are usually a mixture of both).

So if David Haye were to KO both Klitschko brothers (as that's likely his best chance of winning), he'd have beaten two fit, active, focused world champions, both of which are physically bigger and stronger than Haye (surely that must bode well in the P4P stakes). And he'd have been the genuine champion in 2 weight divisions (the only 2 that he could fight in as well). What more do you people want? Oh right I remember he's not American is he.. my mistake.

[-----------]

yea he wins by ko 46 out of 52 times and..this is the same division you said can make haye p4p????im lost here

What???

Not another thicko, and WHEN did I say this larrysmith?