Erik Morales has a better resume than Floyd Mayweather jr

[klipsch speaker]

Erik? We are talking about Barrera, McCullough, Ayala, Jesus Chavez, Carlos Hernandez, Junior Jones, InJin Chi, Manny Pacquiao, Daniel Zaragosa and Kevin Kelley here... Pretty Fookin Solid names right there........
Even more solid than Mayweather Jr IMHO........Whats your take?

[Nick Fury]

Prime Morales knocks Floyd out! And I agree.

[Mary Jane]

Erik? We are talking about Barrera, McCullough, Ayala, Jesus Chavez, Carlos Hernandez, Junior Jones, InJin Chi, Manny Pacquiao, Daniel Zaragosa and Kevin Kelley here... Pretty Fookin Solid names right there........
Even more solid than Mayweather Jr IMHO........Whats your take?

Mayweather beat Chavez and Hernandez first. He'll beat Pacquiao and never lose to him. Mayweather is undefeated with key wins over an undefeated Diego Corrales, Castillo twice, De La Hoya, an undefeated Ricky Hatton. Juan Manuel Marquez is up in 1 month and after that who knows?

[talip bin osman]

PBF got the scalps of genaro, oscar, chico, JLC, hatton, judah, gatti & baldomir...

i think their resumes are pretty even...

what will ultimately make him higher than erik would be his undefeated record, his longer dominance @ a single weight & his better successes in weight scaling...

just my 2 cents...

[enzogabriel]

morales got balls+heart.....i difinitely agree

[MANGLER]

Mr boat buyer's res is lackin at 147. I give him a pass at 140 since Cotto and Hatton weren't ready then. Beyond that, his res is damn good at 130-135. EM's is ****in sick too.

[Xyei]

Mr boat buyer's res is lackin at 147. I give him a pass at 140 since Cotto and Hatton weren't ready then. Beyond that, his res is damn good at 130-135. EM's is ****in sick too.

Yeah, I agree. Resume is weak at WW.

[Fox McCloud]

Erik? We are talking about Barrera, McCullough, Ayala, Jesus Chavez, Carlos Hernandez, Junior Jones, InJin Chi, Manny Pacquiao, Daniel Zaragosa and Kevin Kelley here... Pretty Fookin Solid names right there........
Even more solid than Mayweather Jr IMHO........Whats your take?

Guty Espadas Jr. is another former champion to add to that list.

I do think Morales has a solid resume, but I am inclined to go with Mayweather's resume over it at this point.

The best win of both resumes is Pacquiao I for Morales. Unfortunately, he lost twice after that.

The next best wins are Corrales, Castillo and Castillo.

Then probably Barrera for Morales, but... once again, he lost twice after that.

Hatton probably comes next.

I don't really know after that. But the top is definitely heavy with Mayweather's wins.

[-Hyperion-]

Guty Espadas Jr. is another former champion to add to that list.

I do think Morales has a solid resume, but I am inclined to go with Mayweather's resume over it at this point.

The best win of both resumes is Pacquiao I for Morales. Unfortunately, he lost twice after that.

The next best wins are Corrales, Castillo and Castillo.

Then probably Barrera for Morales, but... once again, he lost twice after that.

Hatton probably comes next.

I don't really know after that. But the top is definitely heavy with Mayweather's wins.

castillo and corrales are better wins than barrera???in what universe, lol.........

if anything hurts morales is the fact that he lost twice to pac and barrera(even though he was in the slide at 130) and how he lost all his last few fights.......

if pacquiao outpoints mayweather, mayweather's rep is gonna take a huge hit.....

[Fox McCloud]

castillo and corrales are better wins than barrera???in what universe, lol.........

if anything hurts morales is the fact that he lost twice to pac and barrera(even though he was in the slide at 130) and how he lost all his last few fights.......

if pacquiao outpoints mayweather, mayweather's rep is gonna take a huge hit.....

Yeah, it would probably move him below Morales in terms of resume, because he does depend on that 0 to make him great.

And idk man, considering how one-sided Castillo and Corrales fights were for Mayweather (the second Castillo one at least), and how much of a beast those dudes were at the weights Mayweather fought them does give me some wiggle room to rank those above his really close win over Barrera (at 122 or 126 depending if you are talking about officially or the way it should have been scored).