Better last two fights on the resume?

[Fox McCloud]

Is this a bait thread?

Uhhh, no?

I think the variety of answers proves it's an okay question.

Plus, there were two lineal champs, a very good lightweight and a guy who won a title at middleweight facing a lightweight... all pretty significant bouts.

I was just curious how people would evaluate these two side by side.

casamayor = lineal champ
hatton = lineal champ


juan diaz = solid lightweight
de la hoya = h0mosexual



PAC's utter devastation of hatton trumps the casamayor win...oscar is a h0mosexual but PAC was never in trouble and bitchslapped oscar for 8 rounds...JMM was on wobbly legs early on against Diaz


slight edge to PAC...like their fights


sorry juan...you lose again

[TheSurgeonMDMPH]

Pacq!

Remember casa lost to santa cruz, diaz got schooled by nate!
Oscar was skeletor on crack and hatton was fraudish. BUT, hatton was considered the best at his jjw level so that gives pacq the edge.

[portuge puncher]

in terms of the bigger names and hyped up "superfights.
its Pac.

in terms of entertaining, and difficult fights.
its JMM.

[kocface]

in terms of pacquiaos the obvious winner, pacquiao.
pacquiao hasnt lost a round last THREE fights
are you guys watching the same sport??? he didnt lose ONE round to diaz, dlh, or hatton, marquez almost got knocked down by juan diaz. both are good but pac wins this arguement

[S.G.]

Marquez edges it in my opinion. Diaz is better than both Hatton and the version of De La Hoya Manny fought.

Plus Casamayor ain't too shabby either

Marquez is doing **** the hard way; while Pacquiao's doing it the smart way

[Fox McCloud]

Marquez edges it in my opinion. Diaz is better than both Hatton and the version of De La Hoya Manny fought.

Plus Casamayor ain't too shabby either

Marquez is doing **** the hard way; while Pacquiao's doing it the smart way

That is a really good way to put it and a really solid quote.

I'll see if I can green K you, because I really like that line.

[Bhopreign]

Marquez without a doubt, went up in weight and knocked out two champs who neither had be knocked out before.

[Silencers]

The Hatton win and the manner in which he beat Hatton was probably better than the Marquez' wins over Casamayor and Diaz as singular fights but the duo of Casamayor and Diaz is probably better than the duo of DLH and Hatton because DLH was shot. So 2 fights combined, it's Marquez but the Hatton win for Pacquiao is the best and most impressive of the bunch IMO because Hatton was the man at 140, was unbeaten at the weight class and he got blown out by Pacquiao in 2.

[BennyST]

Marquez edges it in my opinion. Diaz is better than both Hatton and the version of De La Hoya Manny fought.

Plus Casamayor ain't too shabby either

Marquez is doing **** the hard way; while Pacquiao's doing it the smart way

I agree with this version. While Pac's fights may have been bigger in name value, they were not close to being the better fighters. Marquez for me.

[MaD RoBoT]

Marquez:
Casamayor=grandpa (way past prime,older than DLH)
Juan Diaz=overrated (lost to grandpa Nate)

Pac:
DLH=(past prime)
Hatton=(lineal champ, undefeated at 140)

Pac!