Greatest Four Divison Champ of Modern Era

[strugler]

lineal don't mean **** unless you defend it. I guess you could consider pac a four weight champion but I don't coun the IBO

anyone picking duran is a nut job, duran like pac never defended any title out of their prime weight class.

floyd, pernell and roy all have title defenses outside of their prime weight class

anyone not picking black is a nut job?.......................................GTFOH.

[Silencers]

Leonard would of got bi*ch slapped by PBF!!! Mosley would of beaten him also.

No....just no.

How did you Score fight 2 againts Hearns? just asking bro

Doesn't matter how I scored the first fight, Leonard knocked him out. Period. Second fight I scored for Hearns but it's like saying Norton is better than Ali because I scored 2 fights for him.

[miron_lang]

lineal don't mean **** unless you defend it. I guess you could consider pac a four weight champion but I don't coun the IBO

anyone picking duran is a nut job, duran like pac never defended any title out of their prime weight class.

floyd, pernell and roy all have title defenses outside of their prime weight class

I see. Very interesting criteria.

[F l i c k e r]

No....just no.



Doesn't matter how I scored the first fight, Leonard knocked him out. Period. Second fight I scored for Hearns but it's like saying Norton is better than Ali because I scored 2 fights for him.

imo, i think when you are left with a couple of bruises and your opponent has a detatched retina and retired afterwards.... You won.

I really dont understand the Duran votes. Why Duran, people?

[MaFu MoFo]

Does MODEN ERA includes this current decade or not?

[Silencers]

imo, i think when you are left with a couple of bruises and your opponent has a detatched retina and retired afterwards.... You won.

I really dont understand the Duran votes. Why Duran, people?

He won. Period, there's no question of who won the first fight. Detached retina or not, did Marquez beat Vazquez in their third fight? No but Vazquez was the one bruised up, cut and suffered a detached retina.

[hammerhiem]

Duran or Pac are the greatest Multiweight Fighters, Duran from 122 -> 175 Pac 106 -> 147.

If I was pressed to chose 1 i would take Duran because he did the majority of his multi weight achivements after ruling a division for 9 years.

[VirusTI]

Roy, no question.

Dude went up to the unlimited weight division!!!!...... from 154.


P.S.
P4P Roy beats SRL in the ring.

[Brandish]

He won. Period, there's no question of who won the first fight. Detached retina or not, did Marquez beat Vazquez in their third fight? No but Vazquez was the one bruised up, cut and suffered a detached retina.

we are not talking about one fight we are talking about the greatest 4 weight champion the way I have it is based on accomplishments and title defenses:

1. Roy Jones jr.(most title defenses(22) out of prime weight class)
2. Floyd mayweather jr(12)
3. Pernell Whitaker(13)
4. Tommy Hearns (9)
5. Sugar Ray Leonard (8)
6. Oscar De la hoya jr (8)
7. Roberto Duran (nontitle defenses outside of 135) (0)
8. Manny Pac (no title defenses outside of prime weight class) (0)

[Bogler]

we are not talking about one fight we are talking about the greatest 4 weight champion the way I have it is based on accomplishments and title defenses:

1. Roy Jones jr.(most title defenses(22) out of prime weight class)
2. Floyd mayweather jr(12)
3. Pernell Whitaker(13)
4. Tommy Hearns (9)
5. Sugar Ray Leonard (8)
6. Oscar De la hoya jr (8)
7. Roberto Duran (nontitle defenses outside of 135) (0)
8. Manny Pac (no title defenses outside of prime weight class) (0)

could you list the prime weight classes for each fighter on your list? and how can you tell if that was their prime weight class? what was your criteria? and how do YOU define prime weight class?