Toney Vs. Rahman

[lsk]

I woud go with Rahman on this on

[Colonel Jones]

am i the only one who thinks that James Toney being a reconized heavyweight challenger reflects the sad state of the division. Do people really believe the hype of this guy. I can understand the average fan bying the hype, but the so called experts giving him his props is very perplexing to me. But then again he is one of only 7 fighters to have beaten Holyfield in 10 of his last fights. Who are we kidding here, a prime Holyfield-Toney fight would be so lopsided it wouldn't even be signed.

[guru]

i'd pick toney over rahman... the rock hasn't fooled me by beating a bunch of bums... toney is much more skilled then him...

[RussianArm]

Toney's best win ever was against a good fighter Vasili Jirov, he is done after this fight, fighting a shell of Holyfield and an overweight Booker, I don't see him beating many top fighters in HWY division, he will just make a lot of noise and fade away into bolivian.

[oldgringo]

Toney's best win ever was against a good fighter Vasili Jirov, he is done after this fight, fighting a shell of Holyfield and an overweight Booker, I don't see him beating many top fighters in HWY division, he will just make a lot of noise and fade away into bolivian.

Are you kidding? His best wins ever came against:

1.) Michael Nunn
2.) Mike McCallum x2
3.) Iran Barkley and maybe at this point Jirov...

Jirov wasn't just a good fighter at that point he was the cruiserweight king.

[BrooklynBomber]

I rewatched couple of Toney's fights and now will have to change my opinion. I think he has got what it takes to beat The ROck