Rank Floyd on the P4p list, if he beats Marquez.

[THE REED]

By fighting and beating Marquez he would now be an active undefeated fighter again... 40-0

Where do you rank him after he fights and wins (IF)

[-EX-]

I forgot how the rankings work, well if Marquez loses wouldn't he fall below B-Hop?

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Bernard Hopkins
3. Shane Mosley
4. Miguel Cotto
5. Floyd Mayweather

Would that list be acceptable? Wat ya'll think?

[Burner]

When is the last time Pac beat a p4pound fighter..........

Oscar....Diaz...Hatton.......

He lost both JMM fights.


Anywho.......

1. Mayweather
2. Pac
3. Hopkins
4. Mosley
5. Williams

[Chups]

When is the last time Pac beat a p4pound fighter..........

Oscar....Diaz...Hatton.......

He lost both JMM fights.


Anywho.......

1. Mayweather
2. Pac
3. Hopkins
4. Mosley
5. Williams

He won against his last fight with Marquez and Hatton.

[gingeralbino]

i use a 2 year rule on mine, that would mean floyd beat Hatton and JMM, good enough for 5ish in my book

[K-Nan]

Mid range. This fight doesn't do much for elevating his status. It's just a set-up for a fight with the bigger names.

[Pugilistic™]

When is the last time Pac beat a p4pound fighter..........

Oscar....Diaz...Hatton.......

He lost both JMM fights.


Anywho.......

1. Mayweather
2. Pac
3. Hopkins
4. Mosley
5. Williams

LOL at Williams being 5th. He doesn't belong there yet.

Mayweather beating Marquez at a weight he belongs nowhere near shouldn't put him above Pacquiao who beat Marquez at a weight he was far more comfortable at.

I would have it like this.

1. Pacquiao
2. Hopkins
3. Mayweather
4. Mosley
5. Marquez

Marquez shouldn't fall too far down the list because to be fair he is fighting at a weight he doesn't belong.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

1.Pacquiao
2.Bhop
3.Calderon
4.Vazquez
5:Floyd
6.JMM
7.Cotto
8.Mosley
9.Dachinyan
10.Williams

[BattlingNelson]

By fighting and beating Marquez he would now be an active undefeated fighter again... 40-0

Where do you rank him after he fights and wins (IF)

I wouldn't rank him based on the JMM fight as it IMo carries little significance. That being said Floyd should enter the list based on the fact that his retirement is over and past accomplishments as such.

I think I would put him at about no. 5, but it's always extremely subjective to rank fighters in general and p4p in particular.

[S.G.]

number 2

i feel the top ten P4P is looking a bit weak lately, with Vazquez and F. Marquez being inactive and Cotto losing

I guess my top 5 would be:

#1. Manny Pacquiao
#2. Floyd Mayweather, Jr.
#3. Juan Manuel Marquez
#4. Bernard Hopkins
#5. Shane Mosley or Israel Vazquez