If JMM beats Mayweather..

[- JCHING -]

Would you regard him as a better and more accomplished fighter than Pacquiao?

I certainly would. IMO Marquez has already outdone Pacquiao's stint at lightweight by beating Casamayor and Juan Diaz. If Marquez beats Mayweather at 147 then that will again outdo Pacquiao's victory over ODLH at WW. The only thing left for him to do to solidify his greatness over Pac then is to beat him at 140.

Very far fetched I know, but not out of the question..

[strugler]

not yet.....considering PBF retirement.......which raises some doubts...................

[MANGLER]

No. But a ****in 3rd fight would be a must.

[Roxas]

Would you regard him as a better and more accomplished fighter than Pacquiao?

I certainly would. IMO Marquez has already outdone Pacquiao's stint at lightweight by beating Casamayor and Juan Diaz. If Marquez beats Mayweather at 147 then that will again outdo Pacquiao's victory over ODLH at WW. The only thing left for him to do to solidify his greatness over Pac then is to beat him at 140.

Very far fetched I know, but not out of the question..

yes I would... quite a feat to acomplish for Marquez but not impossible....

[S.G.]

It'd be better than any single win on Pac's resume for certain

Whether it's quite enough for him to fully overtake Pacquiao is debatable. Or maybe not actually

But if he went on to beat Pac then yes it would put him above him

[Sox8055]

Definately.

[rizkybizness]

id die a happy man if JMM beats Mayweather and then officially beats Pac

[Chunk..]

Marquez beating Mayweather would trump over anything Pacquiao has ever done, but like Mangler said - a third fight is essential.

[fallenloki]

If you compare the quality of the opposition each has faced since their last fight, I think it's pretty clear that Marquez would surpass Pacquiao's accomplishments.

Floyd, Juan Diaz, Casamayor >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> David Diaz (who), De La Hoya, Hugman.

[SuperKing]

Its a big if and its a big step for JMM to take but if he somehow managed to do it then yes i would regard him as a more accomplished fighter than Pac.