Higher ATG: Roy or Manny???

[Boxingwizard]

Roy Jones Jr. best wins are

Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Julio Gonzalzes
Reggie Johnson
Antonio Tarver
John Ruiz

Pacquiao's best wins are

Marco Antonio Barerra X2
Ricky Hatton
Juan Manquel Marquez
Erik Morales X2
ODLH
David Diaz
Oscar Larios

[Chr0nic]

we might never see anyone as dominant and as stylish as roy jones, just remember that

[WhoreUs]

Glenn Johnson, Tarver > RJJ
B-Hop > ****d Johnson, schooled Tarver

the only thing bhop is better than roy at......the ONLY thing......is aging better.

roy jumped to 175 because the smaller guys were no challenge (not that the big boys faired any better)

bernard started at 175 and moved down and changed his diet to be able to stay at 160 because he knew it was his best chance to be able to compete.

roy ****s on bernard.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

wow...yesterday it was pernell, today its roy


i love these debates...who woulda thunk it 5 years ago

[THE REED]

It's all good... Roy ran the 90's... He isn't the greatest fighter ever, he doesn't have the best resume ever, real boxing fans know and understand that. But something extremely rare and special, and is great inside his own accomplishments.

[El Dominicano]

Roy Jones Jr. best wins are

Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Julio Gonzalzes
Reggie Johnson
Antonio Tarver
John Ruiz

Pacquiao's best wins are

Marco Antonio Barerra X2
Ricky Hatton
Juan Manquel Marquez
Erik Morales X2
ODLH (who was way past his prime)

Beating B-Hop is better then any win Pacquiao has on his resume. Plus RJJ's win over Toney was equivalent to Pacquiao's win over MAB...or am I wrong here?

[THE REED]

the only thing bhop is better than roy at......the ONLY thing......is aging better.

roy jumped to 175 because the smaller guys were no challenge (not that the big boys faired any better)

bernard started at 175 and moved down and changed his diet to be able to stay at 160 because he knew it was his best chance to be able to compete.

roy ****s on bernard.

Roy ran **** during his 20's and early 30's... and Bhop did during his 30's and early 40's.... they simply aged different... Bernard sealed his legacy better later in age... Roy got their first.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Beating B-Hop is better then any win Pacquiao has on his resume. Plus RJJ's win over Toney was equivalent to Pacquiao's win over MAB...or am I wrong here?

roy beating toney didnt 'shock' anyone

[MELLY-MEL...]

the only thing bhop is better than roy at......the ONLY thing......is aging better.

roy jumped to 175 because the smaller guys were no challenge (not that the big boys faired any better)

bernard started at 175 and moved down and changed his diet to be able to stay at 160 because he knew it was his best chance to be able to compete.

roy ****s on bernard.

i agree...........

[WhoreUs]

Roy Jones Jr. best wins are

Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Julio Gonzalzes
Reggie Johnson
Antonio Tarver
John Ruiz

Pacquiao's best wins are

Marco Antonio Barerra X2
Ricky Hatton
Juan Manquel Marquez
Erik Morales X2
ODLH
David Diaz
Oscar Larios

virgil hill and mike mccallum were very good wins too.