Can someone explain to me how Pacquiao's resume is better/ or comparable to Whitaker?

**aether** · 05-12-2009, 06:32 AM

Originally posted by El Dominicano

Perror made a thread like this and alot of people didn't explain. The usaully, vote and then break out but I'd like for people to explain. I mean

Whitaker's resume
JLR
Hurtado
JCV
JCC
Azumah Nelson
McGirt
Haugen
DLH (Prime) (I felt he won this fight)

Pacquiao's resume
MAB 2x (His best win)
EM Lost, won the 2nd and 3rd (3rd fight was very unnecessary)
JMM Draw, 2nd fight W (Which most people disagree with)
David Diaz (Weakest Title Holder at 135)
Ricky Hatton (Best JR WW, GREAT win)
DLH

Sasakul
Ledwaba (I still don't know who the fcuk this is, explain why he is such a good name on Pacquiao's resume)

So how could Pacquiao's resume be comparable/ or even better then Whitaker's resume?

kinda unfair that you downplay pac's wins huh?

pac has an amazing resume. fought the best people available. got six titles in six different weight class. four linear titles. comparing it with whitaker's is not blasphemy

whitaker takes it though.

**El Dominicano** · 05-12-2009, 06:33 AM

Originally posted by aether

kinda unfair that you downplay pac's wins huh?

pac has an amazing resume. fought the best people available. got six titles in six different weight class. four linear titles. comparing it with whitaker's is not blasphemy

whitaker takes it though.

I didn't downplay anything, I kept it real.

**baracuda** · 05-12-2009, 06:42 AM

pernell=4 division champ and 3 division lineal champ

pacquiao=6 division champ and the only 4 division lineal champ

ledwaba was a champ with 33-1 record at jr featherweight at that time

**El Dominicano** · 05-12-2009, 06:45 AM

Originally posted by baracuda

pernell=4 division champ and 3 division lineal champ

pacquiao=6 division champ and the only 4 division lineal champ

ledwaba was a champ with 33-1 record at jr featherweight at that time

Who did Ledwaba beat? Please explain teacher

**Boxer1590** · 05-12-2009, 06:49 AM

Originally posted by El Dominicano

Perror made a thread like this and alot of people didn't explain. The usaully, vote and then break out but I'd like for people to explain. I mean

Whitaker's resume
JLR
Hurtado
JCV
JCC
Azumah Nelson
McGirt
Haugen
DLH (Prime) (I felt he won this fight)

Pacquiao's resume
MAB 2x (His best win)
EM Lost, won the 2nd and 3rd fight (3rd fight was unnecessary)
JMM Draw, 2nd fight W (Which most people disagree with)
David Diaz (Weakest Title Holder at 135)
Ricky Hatton (Best JR WW, GREAT win)
DLH

Sasakul
Ledwaba (I still don't know who the fcuk this is, explain why he is such a good name on Pacquiao's resume)

So how could Pacquiao's resume be comparable/ or even better then Whitaker's resume?

lol you list all Sweet Peas victories and then make a comment downplaying all Pacquiao's.

Barrera, Morales, Marquez all better than Hurtado, McGirt, Haugen, Jose Luis Ramirez, and an old Azumah Nelson. They both fouight De La Hoya but Pac jumped up 2 weight classes and knocked him out.
On top of that, Pacquiao knocked out Hatton.

Pac won more titles in more divisions.

Pac is more exciting.

Pac > Sweet Pea

**Breadbin** · 05-12-2009, 06:50 AM

Originally posted by El Dominicano

Perror made a thread like this and alot of people didn't explain. The usaully, vote and then break out but I'd like for people to explain. I mean

Whitaker's resume
JLR
Hurtado
JCV
JCC
Azumah Nelson
McGirt
Haugen
DLH (Prime) (I felt he won this fight)

Pacquiao's resume
MAB 2x (His best win)
EM Lost, won the 2nd and 3rd fight (3rd fight was unnecessary)
JMM Draw, 2nd fight W (Which most people disagree with)
David Diaz (Weakest Title Holder at 135)
Ricky Hatton (Best JR WW, GREAT win)
DLH

Sasakul
Ledwaba (I still don't know who the fcuk this is, explain why he is such a good name on Pacquiao's resume)

So how could Pacquiao's resume be comparable/ or even better then Whitaker's resume?

Azumah Nelson

**Silencers** · 05-12-2009, 06:57 AM

Ledwaba didn't beat anyone of note but he was highly regarded because of his performance on the Lewis-Rahman 1 undercard which wowed the guys at HBO, they were planning on grooming Ledwaba as the next big thing at 122 but what they got instead was Pacquiao.

Anyways, their resumes aren't that far apart in terms of opposition fought and beaten, Pacquiao also has pretty good wins against Larios, Hussein and possibly Solis, depending on what Solis goes on to do, he actually looks like a pretty good fighter, would like to see what he can do at a higher class though.

**El Dominicano** · 05-12-2009, 06:58 AM

Originally posted by RTS

lol you list all Sweet Peas victories and then make a comment downplaying all Pacquiao's.

Barrera, Morales, Marquez all better than Hurtado, McGirt, Haugen, Jose Luis Ramirez, and an old Azumah Nelson. They both fouight De La Hoya but Pac jumped up 2 weight classes and knocked him out.
On top of that, Pacquiao knocked out Hatton.

Pac won more titles in more divisions.

Pac is more exciting.

Pac > Sweet Pea

Azumah Nelson was 32, weird how you pretty much know what Whitaker has accomplished yet you say Pacquiao's resume is better.

**El Dominicano** · 05-12-2009, 06:58 AM

Originally posted by Breadbin

Azumah Nelson

Only an idiot!

Can someone explain to me how Pacquiao's resume is better/ or comparable to Whitaker?