POLL: Clottey Top WW material?

[MaFu MoFo]

The best Welterweight is Floyd Mayweather Jr.

Fact.

Ugh only if Floyd loses to JMM.

Clottey could beat Cotto, Mosley, and every other ranked WW and he still wouldn't be the best because last I checked Floyd unretired.

Also lol he's super overrated.

PBF was the best WW in 2006...


Dude, to be the TOP WW, you got to BEAT THE BEST WW's in the DIVISION... Hatton doesn't count as a win in the WW Div as "one of the best WW's in the division". But you may enlight me on who has PBF beated in the WW Div since Baldomir???

[Iceta]

That question is gonna be answered when he fights Cotto. I think Clottey has some good attributes but one thing that he does that I don't have a very high opinion of is he tends to be inconsistent with his offense. Even though I have compared that trait that he has to that of Chad Dawson, I think he has a better chin than Dawson does and he is a harder puncher for his respective weight class than Dawson is for light-heavy. He also has a better defense than Dawson.

[Jean28]

If he beats Cotto and Mosley then he is #1 WW.

[MaFu MoFo]

That question is gonna be answered when he fights Cotto. I think Clottey has some good attributes but one thing that he does that I don't have a very high opinion of is he tends to be inconsistent with his offense. Even though I have compared that trait that he has to that of Chad Dawson, I think he has a better chin than Dawson does and he is a harder puncher for his respective weight class than Dawson is for light-heavy. He also has a better defense than Dawson.

Dude, those are big words you just posted. I disagree.