Who's better Jose L. Castillo or Juan M. Marquez

[dsyef]

Somebody wants to know whos better Jose Luis Castillo or Juan Manuel Marquez. You be the Judge. Compare them if you like, but say whos the better fighter.

[JACK D. RIPPER]

Tough choice, but JMM is better in every department but size. Though his skill set makes up for it.

[talip bin osman]

Tough choice, but JMM is better in every department but size. Though his skill set makes up for it.

i politely disagree my man...

castillo is a lot better inside fighter... castillo is better in cutting the ring also IMO...

[boxasmash]

marquez easily.

[El Dominicano]

i politely disagree my man...

castillo is a lot better inside fighter... castillo is better in cutting the ring also IMO...

JLC is the better brawler, JMM is the better boxer. Now, if they faced eachother, JLC would KTFO JMM

[talip bin osman]

JLC is the better brawler, JMM is the better boxer. Now, if they faced eachother, JLC would KTFO JMM

inside fighting or cutting the ring is not brawling... as with any technique, it is part of a boxer's skillset...

bobby chacon, rafael limon, gatti, ward, katsidis & barrios are the genuine brawlers... castillio isnt of those...

[ACHlLLES]

Marquez and its not even close

[JACK D. RIPPER]

JLC is the better brawler, JMM is the better boxer. Now, if they faced eachother, JLC would KTFO JMM

If they fought I'd be more of a chess match than a brawl. Plus, JMM's shown he can brawl w/ the best of them: MAB, Diaz, and Packy.

[FasTHarD]

Marquez is better but size made the difference.

[Dirt E Gomez]

Decent question. Castillo fought long and hard and his body couldn't deal with it. Despite being the same age they just aren't the same age in the ring.

Castillo has had his fair share of big and imortant wins, as has Marquez. I honestly probably place it at a dead heat, but on this forum I guarantee Marquez will be put well ahead. Ask this poll 2 years ago and you'd get a very different outcome.