Manny to tip off at 147?

[Benny Leonard]

If Cotto gets through Clottey I think he should be the man at WW

Q(W went on the become champ)
Judah (W former Lineal champ)
Mosley(W HOF champ
Margarito (L former champ...Very su****ious)
Clottey (????champ)

4 out of 5 ... with that type of competition....and the only loss under su****ion of Tom Foolery...?

Not to shabby




Not taking Clottey lightly....just saying.

Cotto was knocked out by Margarito who was then knocked out by Shane. Shane and Cotto would have to square off again...especially since it was a close fight.

[MANGLER]

Don't do it Pac. Suicide.

[BOOMbip]

Cotto was knocked out by Margarito who was then knocked out by Shane. Shane and Cotto would have to square off again...especially since it was a close fight.

Can't find a way to disagree with that.

one thing though...

Lets say Margarito never got caught cheating...lets say he never cheated and Mosley wooped his ass...and he just had a regular loss and he wasnt disgraced or banned.

Would Cotto be ahead or behind him in your eyes as top fighters at WW...I mean you could argue that the type manner of victory would seperate them ...one being a brutal stoppage and one being a UD.

All that being said Cotto beat the man that Beat Margarito...(still pretending he never cheated) Does that put him in a better spot then Margarito??? the man that put an ass whoopin on him?

Thats the same logic that is being used with Shane and Cotto.

[Benny Leonard]

Can't find a way to disagree with that.

one thing though...

Lets say Margarito never got caught cheating...lets say he never cheated and Mosley wooped his ass...and he just had a regular loss and he wasnt disgraced or banned.

Would Cotto be ahead or behind him in your eyes as top fighters at WW...I mean you could argue that the type manner of victory would seperate them ...one being a brutal stoppage and one being a UD.

All that being said Cotto beat the man that Beat Margarito...(still pretending he never cheated) Does that put him in a better spot then Margarito??? the man that put an ass whoopin on him?

Thats the same logic that is being used with Shane and Cotto.

Cotto would have to fight Margarito; Shane would have to fight Cotto.

They all might basically be even...except Shane was never knocked out and the fight with Cotto was close, so that might put him ahead in the fans eyes.



Ring has it:

Champion: Vacant

#1 Mosley
#2 Cotto
#3 Margarito