Mayweather vs. Pavlik or JMM vs. Mayweather. Equally (un)fair?

[BattlingNelson]

..i said floyd beats both any way so it doesnt matter..

Funny because you must have cast your vote wrong then. You voted that the JMM fight was fair but obviously you meant that the Pavlik fight is fair as well or...?

[larry x]

Quoted for truth

we all saw what happened when kelly fought a defensive genius..he looked like a big goofy idiot..imagine him trying to hit a smaller faster floyd.....that **** would be to funny..so i dont see the issue with this thread....floyd ko'd jmm and shuts pavlik out..120-108

[ИATAS]

You can make an arguement that it's fair or it's unfair, the whole thing with me is that JMM CALLED out Floyd, he wanted to fight Floyd. Floyd is being generous going down a few pounds imo.

Typically, in boxing when a smaller fighter challenges a bigger fighter, almost always its the little guy stepping up since he was the one that initiated the challenge.

So if JMM gets his ass kicked you cant really feel bad for him since he's the one that wanted the fight.

[BattlingNelson]

All you have to do is look at Marquez next to Floyd and picture Floyd next to Pavlik. Really after picturing that there is no more to be said.

Weight difference is the same in both fights. There maybe difference in height but as said several times there aint no rules about height.

Pull another one.

[larry x]

Funny because you must have cast your vote wrong then. You voted that the JMM fight was fair but obviously you meant that the Pavlik fight is fair as well or...?

i voted before reading the thread........

[THE REED]

Both these fights are ****** as ****.

How? I think Floyd could DEFINITELY beat pavlik for a MW title...

[BattlingNelson]

You can make an arguement that it's fair or it's unfair, the whole thing with me is that JMM CALLED out Floyd, he wanted to fight Floyd. Floyd is being generous going down a few pounds imo.

Typically, in boxing when a smaller fighter challenges a bigger fighter, almost always its the little guy stepping up since he was the one that initiated the challenge.

So if JMM gets his ass kicked you can feel bad for him.

I'm really only talking fairness here. If Floyd fought everone who has called him out through the years his resumée would be full of legit welters by now.

[Vasyl’s dad]

You can make an arguement that it's fair or it's unfair, the whole thing with me is that JMM CALLED out Floyd, he wanted to fight Floyd. Floyd is being generous going down a few pounds imo.

Typically, in boxing when a smaller fighter challenges a bigger fighter, almost always its the little guy stepping up since he was the one that initiated the challenge.

So if JMM gets his ass kicked you can feel bad for him.

Do you really believe Floyd came back simply because Marquez called him out?

I don't think you really do.

If you do, whats your take on Margarito calling Floyd out?

[Bhopreign]

Weight difference is the same in both fights. There maybe difference in height but as said several times there aint no rules about height.

Pull another one.

To answser your other post, Hearns is 6'1, Leonard 5'10, thats 3 inches not 5. What it boils down to is where a fighter is effective. Its not about weight, but where he is effective. Floyd wouldnt be as effective at 160 as he is at 147 and below.

[BattlingNelson]

i voted before reading the thread........

So you would say that both fights are fair?