How much credit would Oscar have gotten if he had beaten Floyd at 154???

[strugler]

Are you ***ing ******?

I am comparing to same situations.

Pbf was number one WW fought Oscar at 154

Pacman will be number one Jr WW and fight Floyd at 147

Has Oscar won what would the fight do for his legacy?

If Floyd wins what will it do for his legacy

Youre asking Pac to fight floyd at 147 cause he fought Oscar.........When PBF fought and beat Oscar at 154 no surely expected him to fight at 154 again......its an Oscar lottery ....floyd aint Oscar financially.......

[boxasmash]

hatton was number 1 jww and he fought mayweather and lost, doesnt mean ****. weight divisions are there for a reason, unless floyd beats pac at his own weight class then it doesnt mean jack ****.

[Rich Loc]

hatton was number 1 jww and he fought mayweather and lost, doesnt mean ****. weight divisions are there for a reason, unless floyd beats pac at his own weight class then it doesnt mean jack ****.

What is Pernell Whitaker best win????

[RL_GMA]

In all fairness, Floyd was jumping up a few pounds to fight Oscar and he came in at what, 150? Plus, Floyd was barely 30 yrs old and in prime shape.

In comparison to JMM, he'd be coming up 2 weight classes from 135 to 147 and is going on 38 years old and has been in way more brutal fights than Floyd's ever seen along with never even fighting above 140.

Plus, Oscar wasn't even the favorite in the fight and Floyd called for the fight at either weight (147 or 154). He met the Jr Middle limit and beat an inactive Oscar. Big name on Floyd's resume which he deserves credit for, put let's be real...that was not the Oscar that made his mark on the sport. Not as bad a beating obviously, but its like Oscar beating Chavez in the sense of the younger lion beating the older lion, nothing new in the world of Boxing.

He's going to fight a Welterweight, not necessarily a top guy yet, but they'll be a Welterweight.

[PrettyBoy22]

He didn't beat him, so theres not that much point debating it.

It would of been a great win of course, but you'd still get the sceptics saying a re-match at WW should be made

[boxasmash]

What is Pernell Whitaker best win????

chavez wasn't officially a win anyway so your point is mute. chavez and whitaker were about the same size, pernell only had 2 or 3 welterweight fights and near enough skipped jww.

mayweather has been fighting at 140+ for 4 years, pacquiao has just 1 fight.

[Rich Loc]

chavez wasn't officially a win anyway so your point is mute. chavez and whitaker were about the same size, pernell only had 2 or 3 welterweight fights and near enough skipped jww.

mayweather has been fighting at 140+ for 4 years, pacquiao has just 1 fight.

JCC/Pernell can be the same size yet PBF/Pac cannot

Mayweather fight night weight 149
Pacman fight night weight 148


Pacman has proved himself at WW while JCC didn't

[Deja_Vous]

Oscar was *****, Now floyd aint no OSCAR but........COME on 143-144 sounds fair enough for me........if JMM refuse this his a *****.if PAC refused this theyre both bitches....and Oscar he is a *****( for fighting a lightweight/SFW)

143-144 would be fair IF Mayweather called-out Marquez.

If JMM ddin't want to fight at 147 he should have kept his gay ass quiet.

[F-22 Raptor]

How much credit would Oscar have gotten if he had beaten Floyd at 154???

I dont know flawless, who cares about hypothetical situations like that? Floyd won, ew get it, happy?

[Pullcounter]

How much credit would Oscar have gotten if he had beaten Floyd at 154???

if dlh beat floyd, he'd get mad credit no doubt.

so many haters wants to see floyd lose