Who has the better record, Floyd or Freddie?

[Me La Pelan]

Reading the transcript from the interview they had, I wondered this question myself. Who has the better record in your opinion and why?

Floyd Mayweather Sr.
http://www.boxrec.com/list_bouts.php...5480&cat=boxer


OR


Freddie Roach
http://www.boxrec.com/list_bouts.php...3014&cat=boxer

Not training-wise, but their actual pro boxing career.

[Steak]

Roach actually might have the better career, although Sr was the better fighter.

Roach is a far better trainer than Sr tho.

[F l i c k e r]

Roach had a better career than Sr. in my opinion. The dude was ranked 8th in the world before the parkinsons.

[Me La Pelan]

I think floyd might edge out freddie, Floyd got K.O'd by Sugar Ray in the 10th,
Freddie got KO'd by Greg "FEATHERFISTED" Haugen in 7.
Floyd took Starling the distance twice, Roach took Camacho and Chacon the distance.....

[Steak]

Roach had a better career than Sr. in my opinion. The dude was ranked 8th in the world before the parkinsons.

I dont remember Roach being rated 8th at any time.

Sr was rated as high as 6th in the world at one time though, although it didnt last long.

Roach is probably still more accomplished than Sr though

[street bully]

You have got to admit that Sr is in ridiculous shape for a 56 year old man. Vargas should be ashamed of himself.

[Me La Pelan]

You have got to admit that Sr is in ridiculous shape for a 56 year old man. Vargas should be ashamed of himself.

LMAO , hell yeah

[Left Hook Tua]

floyd sr. is probably more skilled but roach had the longer and better career.

as trainers......no contest. floyd sr. ain't on roach's level.

[Me La Pelan]

floyd sr. is probably more skilled but roach had the longer and better career.

as trainers......no contest. floyd sr. ain't on roach's level.

How was it better Lefty? break it down

[TheGreatA]

Roach actually might have the better career, although Sr was the better fighter.

Agreed.

I feel that Mayweather Sr had a lot of potential which was not realized. Roach made the most out of what he had and fought some of the best fighters at the time.

Floyd Mayweather was once ranked the number 5 challenger in the world.