If Pac Beats Ricky, but JMM beat PBF who's # 1?

[koboy]

I'm going to say JMM here.

[Kevin Jesus]

Juan Manuel Marquez.

[THe TRiNiTY]

I'd go with Marquez. He fought well against the guy who's NOW number one. And so that cancels out Hatton. Marquez would have an even bigger win, against a clearly better fighter. I'd give Juan the nod. Nonetheless, I wouldn't argue with people who kept Marquez at two.

[koboy]

I wouldn't argue with people who kept Marquez at two.

But Floyd is a bigger fish and he's already beaten Hatton. I think JMM has to be ranked higher than Pac if he beats PBF.

[goblin]

When u guys rate someone at a P4P position..How many fights do u go back? Their last 5 fights? How many is it? Cause based on Jmm's and Manny's last 5 i think Jmm has fought tougher opposition.

[Dan...]

I think it would be very close but I would stick with Pacquiao just.

[loui_ludwig]

When u guys rate someone at a P4P position..How many fights do u go back? Their last 5 fights? How many is it? Cause based on Jmm's and Manny's last 5 i think Jmm has fought tougher opposition.

Marquez fought Barrera, Juarez, and Pac at 130 then Casa and JDiaz at 135.

Pac fougth Solis, Barrera, and JMM at 130 then DDiaz at 135 and Oscar at 147.

[Ido]

Questions like these are left unanswered. 1 victory, is not enough to disregard previous, recent accomplishments. Its better to go the 3rd showdown to simply settle, who deserves the recognitions.

[koboy]

When u guys rate someone at a P4P position..How many fights do u go back? Their last 5 fights? How many is it? Cause based on Jmm's and Manny's last 5 i think Jmm has fought tougher opposition.

Definitely, but I think Manny is # 1 because he has already beaten Marquez and moved up to weight classes to beat Oscar convincingly. Regardless of how weight drained Oscar was that night, Manny won despite every expert not giving him a chance to win.

But I think, if JMM beats PBF, a former # 1, while Manny beats a guy around # 8 on many P4P lists, JMM should get the nod.

[S.G.]

if JMM beats Mayweather and then wins the 3rd fight against Pacman, will he be considered the greater fighter?