If Mayweather Fought...

[sandyvahra]

There's a consensus that floyd hasn't fought the best, avoids top challenges, ducked fighters in the past, etc etc.

However, if he fought Paul Williams would that in your eyes erase any questions about floyds heart, willingness to test his limits, and erase all the fights that shoulda coulda woulda been made?

Win loss or draw here.

I vote yes

[kmcc505]

Me 2. Floyd versus Paul Williams erases all doubts.

[Main Event]

But if he beats Paul they'll say hes ducking Cotto and when he beats Cotto they'll say he's ducking Mosley and then when he beats Mosley they'll say he's duckin Margarito..............You cant make everyone happy

[Weebler I]

But if he beats Paul they'll say hes ducking Cotto and when he beats Cotto they'll say he's ducking Mosley and then when he beats Mosley they'll say he's duckin Margarito..............You cant make everyone happy

he could always... I dunno...fight them? imagine that.

[sandyvahra]

But if he beats Paul they'll say hes ducking Cotto and when he beats Cotto they'll say he's ducking Mosley and then when he beats Mosley they'll say he's duckin Margarito..............You cant make everyone happy

I disagree. I harp on floyd's opposition as much as anyone. I question his resume and all time status more than anyone. I would love to see him ktfo by cotto/mosley. I question his willingness and hunger to reach his full potential.

And I can honestly say if he fought williams, regardless of outcome Id never question the man again.

[Main Event]

he could always... I dunno...fight them? imagine that.

You gave Hatton 5 rounds? Really?

[12Rounds]

But if he beats Paul they'll say hes ducking Cotto and when he beats Cotto they'll say he's ducking Mosley and then when he beats Mosley they'll say he's duckin Margarito..............You cant make everyone happy

I don't think mayweather would want to lose three times in a row.

[The Hammer]

If Floyd fought Williams, I would respect him.

But he never will...

Williams represents a risk Mayweather is too cowardly to take. Floyd's next opponent will be Vasquez, or maybe Calderon.

[Weebler I]

You gave Hatton 5 rounds? Really?

yeah pitty patty punches mean nothing to me

[-EX-]

Paul Williams hasn't touched 147 in a while and Floyd aint fighting that freak. Cotto, Mosley would make sense.

But those who dislike Floyd would find an excuse anyway...

O Shane was washed up or past prime(true), or Cotto was damaged goods, or Floyd ran all night...